Democrats and Republicans alike have decried Stephen Miller’s promotion to White House chief of staff, but a cross section of advocacy and faith groups also has joined the chorus of condemnation.
The complaints against Miller begin first and foremost with his role as the architect of the administration’s brutal immigrant detention and deportation campaign. Others cite his ties to white supremacist and Christian nationalist ideologies, support for Israel’s military operations in Gaza and stances that make him a threat to American Jews.
United Methodist megachurch pastor and U.S. Senator-elect Adam Hamilton said he found the president’s decision surprising.
“The election was a repudiation of so much of what Trump has stood for and I think so much of that was designed by Stephen Miller, so the idea of making him chief of staff seems really odd to me, the Democrat said on CNN’s State of the Nation. “And it’s concerning. It feels like a doubling down on what the first two years of the Trump administration has done and what I appreciate is the fact that people in my state, which is typically a pretty red state, have said this is not OK, this is not who we are.”
Trump fired Chief of Staff Susie Wiles and promoted Miller in her place three days after Democrats scored major state and federal victories in the 2026 midterms. Miller’s first day on the job was Nov. 9.
“We expect this appointment to only reinforce some of the most dangerous ways the administration has normalized antisemitism and broader extremism,” said Amy Spitalnick, CEO of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs, in a Jewish Telegraph report.
“At the core of the anti-immigrant agenda Miller has spearheaded are deeply antisemitic conspiracy theories about ‘replacement’ and ‘invasion’ that have already fueled a cycle of deadly violence targeting Jews and others,” she said.
The trouncing the president and Republican politicians suffered in the midterm “blue wave” has largely been attributed to inflation and the war in Iran, but post-election polling has shown large numbers of Americans disapprove of the administration’s handling of immigration. According to NBC News exit polling, a majority of American (57%) agreed Miller’s deportation campaign had “gone too far.”
“Trump handed a promotion to the architect of chaos, cruelty and callousness.”
But just as the president has, the Department of Homeland Security doubled down by boasting Nov. 12 that Immigration and Customs Enforcement arrested 491,000 people and deported 483,000 in fiscal year 2026. In 2025, the agency reported 442,640 deportations.
Under Miller’s direction, the Department of Homeland Security unleashed a surge of violent immigration enforcement actions across the nation with emphasis on large cities in Democratic-controlled states such as California, Illinois, Minnesota and New York. Protesters, many of them clergy, have been brutalized and detained and churches like University Baptist Church in Minneapolis been spied on by ICE.
Miller’s policies have resulted in at least 23 medical deaths in ICE detention facilities while agents clearly have been given the green light to use seemingly deadly force against immigrants and Americans alike.
According to CBS News, at least nine people have died in at least 30 ICE-involved shootings during Trump’s second term. American citizens Renee Good and Alex Pretti were shot to death by agents during demonstrations in Minneapolis earlier this year.
“A little over three hours after Alex was shot for trying to help his neighbor, Miller lied and said that ‘A domestic terrorist tried to assassinate federal law enforcement.’ Yet this is who Trump chose,” said Doug Pagitt, executive director of Vote Common Good.
Even more baffling is that the president, in a recent interview with 60 Minutes, admitted Miller’s crackdown is “too tough,” Pagitt noted. “But he still just handed the White House to the man who built (the program), with $75 billion in new money behind ICE.”
Pagitt also added his voice to those calling for Miller’s removal and said Democrats must immediately investigate his immigration policies when they take control of Congress next year: “We always have to stay vigilant.”
Naming Miller his chief of staff sends a clear message Trump is doubling down on the administration’s immigration strategy, said Vanessa Cardenas, executive director of the immigrant advocacy group America’s Voice.
“Trump blamed his staff (for the election outcomes) and handed a promotion to the architect of chaos, cruelty and callousness. Stephen Miller is responsible for the masked agents in our neighborhoods, the U.S. citizens beaten and detained, the families torn apart, and the lives lost from Minneapolis to Biddeford (Maine),” she said. “Elevating him is an act of open disdain toward a nation that just rebuked this agenda.”
The Latino civil rights group UnidosUS said Miller’s ties to white nationalists likely affected the defection of Hispanic and Black Americans who voted for Trump in 2024.
“There is no greater sign that Donald Trump is ‘giving the middle finger’ to millions of American voters and the message they sent to his administration on Tuesday than his disastrous decision to name Stephen Miller his chief of staff,” said Janet Murguia, president of UnidosUS.
“Voters overwhelmingly rejected the cruelty and abusive overreach of mass deportation. Miller is not only the architect of that campaign but also has led the way in smearing and lying about the unarmed, nonviolent migrants and U.S. citizens unjustly killed by his immigration force.”
Related:
Stephen Miller must be confused about gender identity | Opinion by Mark Wingfield
Stephen Miller, we know what you’re doing | Opinion by Catherine Meeks
Stephen Miller is Plato’s original playground bully | Opinion by Rodney Kennedy
What you’re not seeing: Tens of thousands of children separated from parents




