The United Nations held its annual climate change conference, COP28, late last year but produced little to show for its efforts.
The U.N.’s Conference on Parties — meaning “all parties in the world” — met for the 28th straight year, thus the name COP28.
The primary objective of each conference is to help the world avoid a global temperature rise of more than 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. Scientists say this is the tipping point at which cataclysmic events will begin to take place, such as melting ice sheets, loss of coral reef, rising sea levels leading to massive land loss, human displacement and chaotic ocean movements.
The conference, which hosted leaders from 200 nations, including 154 heads of state, was doomed to failure from the start. Why?
First, the president of COP28, Sultan Al Jaber, is the chief executive of the United Arab Emirates’ largest oil company, Adnoc. The company is planning a massive expansion of its oil and gas operations.
Before the meetings began, Al Jaber planned to use them as a lobbying opportunity to sell his company’s products. He is a symbol and incarnation of the oil and gas lobbyists’ control of the conference. The conference attracted 85,000 people, including 2,456 registered lobbyists.
“Greenwashing” signifies a group gives the appearance of caring for the environment but in reality masks its continued degradation of the earth.
The power of the lobbyists led to an outcome called “greenwashing,” a term that signifies a group gives the appearance of caring for the environment but in reality masks its continued degradation of the earth.
Second, COP28, like all previous such conferences, required consensus for approval of all major decisions. This means all 200 states must agree on the language of the agreements, essentially giving veto power to each participating state.
The “pretrostates” — countries that are the largest producers of fossil fuels, like Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates — can wield the threat of veto to assure language is favorable to the fossil fuel industry.
Sultan Ahmed Al Jaber, President of the UNFCCC COP28 Climate Conference, speaks during a plenary session on day thirteen of the UNFCCC COP28 Climate Conference on December 13, 2023 in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. The conference has gone into an extra day as delegations continue to negotiate over the wording of the final agreement. The COP28, which was originally scheduled to run from November 30 through December 12, has brought together stakeholders, including international heads of state and other leaders, scientists, environmentalists, indigenous peoples representatives, activists and others to discuss and agree on the implementation of global measures towards mitigating the effects of climate change. (Photo by Fadel Dawod/Getty Images)
In COP28, the significance of this power was seen in the consensus agreement to “transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems” rather than the more meaningful phrase “phase out from fossil fuel.” The “transition away” phrase is seen as yet another stalling tactic from the fossil fuel industry to maintain their profits as long as possible.
“The lack of an agreement to phase out fossil fuels was devastating,” said Michael Mann, a climatologist and geophysicist at the University of Pennsylvania. “To ‘transition away from fossil fuels’ was weak tea at best. It’s like promising your doctor that you will ‘transition away from doughnuts’ after being diagnosed with diabetes.”
Third, the commitment to Third World countries — which produce the least amount of greenhouse gases while experiencing the greatest impact of climate change — is too small and slow to make any real difference.
The richest nations, including the United States and China, have pledged a mere $400 million to a “Loss and Damage Fund” to compensate for disaster relief resulting from global warming extreme weather events. This, however, is a small fraction of the $400 billion needed annually.
Bareesh Chowdhury of the Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers’ Association said: “Without money and means of implementation, the places worst hit by climate change are left with only empty pockets and empty promises. We need billions of dollars, (but) we’ve been given peanuts, and even more debt to boot.”
Bangladesh is one of the countries most vulnerable to extreme weather and slow-onset impacts, such as sea-level rise.
Twenty-eight years after the first COP, greenhouse gases from fossil fuel emissions are expected to reach 37 million metric tons this year, the most in history. While governments have made some pledges to reduce emissions by 2030, most, including the United States, are far from their target goals.
Without a drastic decrease in the greenhouse gases released into the atmosphere, the earth is on a trajectory of more severe weather events, leading to a tipping point that would alter civilization as we know it.
Without a drastic decrease in the greenhouse gases released into the atmosphere, the earth is on a trajectory of more severe weather events, leading to a tipping point that would alter civilization as we know it.
We are seeing the impact of climate change already. Last year not only set the record for most greenhouse gas emissions, it was the hottest year in recorded history. The scientific prognostications of the 1970s are coming to fruition today. As predicted, global temperatures are increasing, sea levels are rising, species are being extinguished and extreme weather events are becoming normalized.
Climate activists protest to demand a phase out of fossil fuels on day twelve at the UNFCCC COP28 Climate Conference on December 12, 2023 in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. Delegations met late into the night yesterday and are continuing negotiations today over the wording of the final agreement, with the removal of a “phase out” of fossil fuels in yesterday’s Presidential draft apparently among the most contentious issues. The COP28, which is running from November 30 through December 12, is bringing together stakeholders, including international heads of state and other leaders, scientists, environmentalists, indigenous peoples representatives, activists and others to discuss and agree on the implementation of global measures towards mitigating the effects of climate change. (Photo by Sean Gallup/Getty Images)
All of this supports the claim that the Conference of the Parties has been hijacked by fossil fuel lobbyists and the petrostates within which they muster their credibility. Climate activist Greta Thunberg said COP28 was “a stab in the back” of all the nations that are most impacted by climate change.
Next year’s COP29 will be held in Azerbaijan, another petrostate, thus promising more of the same. Fossil fuel lobbyists and petrostates will show up in force, protecting their short-term interests.
The trajectory we are on, leading to a chaotic future, appears to be unaffected by anything happening at COPs. Something has to change. Of course, something is going to change. The change can be intentional, or it can be destructive. In either case, the change will come.
Perhaps we should leave behind the COPs and create a structure more likely to save us from ourselves.
Don Gordon is the founder and CEO of C3, Christians Caring for Creation. After 35 years of teaching and preaching in churches, Christian colleges and seminaries, he is devoting this season of his life to the care of creation. Recognition that climate change is the existential challenge drove his decision. of our generation.
Related articles:
Christians and climate change: A chance to take the Bible seriously
The fantastical world of climate change denial: Slouching toward annihilation
Ways to care for God’s creation this summer
Church and creation care: We need a theology-before-politics approach