You probably know that John Brown was an abolitionist who raided the armory in Harpers Ferry, Va. (now in West Virginia), to strike a blow against slavery. But what you probably didn’t know is that Brown was the first person executed for treason in the United States for that raid. He was executed by the state of Virginia on Dec. 2, 1859.
But aside from the portrayals of Brown’s actions as madness or terrorism or martyrdom, too little of American Christendom pays attention to John Brown, let alone homage. But I think more should, especially if the challenge to the rise of white Christian nationalism is going to come from the ranks of believers, as it most definitely should.
What would it mean to be a John Brown Christian today?
Most people would balk at the idea of following in the footsteps of Brown, a militant abolitionist who believed in direct, even violent, action to overthrow systemic evil, because they think violence is not the answer to people other than themselves getting what they need. However, I would challenge those people, particularly white Christians, who would dismiss the need to respond to violent oppression with anything less than direct action of some kind, even if armed struggle is not included in that action.
How did the world react to the Nazi threat? Did the Soviet Union, China, the U.S., the UK and other countries in the Allied Forces decide that endlessly negotiating with Hitler was the way? Did they try to appeal to his morality? Did they pray for God to change his heart? Did they avoid going to full-on war with the Nazis because they believed violence was not the answer to ending genocide against Jews and other “unacceptable” peoples, like the Roma, the disabled, the socialists and communists, homosexuals and transgender people — who were the first to be targeted in book-burning campaigns — or the Namibians and Nama in Africa before the Nazi Holocaust even happened?
No, they did not. Most white Christians are not opposed to violence, and in my book I examine the ways many support violence against certain groups of people based on twisted, false and ungodly misinterpretations of Scripture used as a cover for personal bias and racism. Few Christians are standing between those forces and their targets, even in the most passive, nonviolent ways, today, nor have they throughout history.
But for those who are standing and who realize they are outside the dictates for how we Christians are supposed to engage with injustice against our fellow man, what does it mean for white Christians today to be like John Brown, even if taking up arms like Brown did is not the path they choose?
“Brown saw slavery as an absolute immoral evil that demanded immediate destruction.”
First, there needs to be a reckoning among white Christians about what evil is, what it is not and what determines who and what they will oppose. Do Christians want to fight gay people for being gay because they think Scripture tells them homosexuality is sin, or do Christians want to fight those who discriminate against, deny rights to, physically attack and murder gay people because discrimination, oppression, assault and murder are wrong?
For white Christians to have an uncompromising opposition to injustice as Brown did and as the Bible commands us to, we need to be clear on what injustice is, rather than insisting on what we disapprove of being the greater sin than the degradation of human beings.
Brown saw slavery as an absolute immoral evil that demanded immediate destruction because Scripture says oppression of the poor, the orphan, the widow, the least among us, is evil that God hates.
Proverbs 14:31 tells us, “Whoever oppresses the poor shows contempt for their Maker, but whoever is kind to the needy honors God.”
Brown did not go into what those individuals did or did not do in their personal lives. He focused on the biblical guidance on how God would have the people who are being mistreated set free by those who claim to love God. For Brown, biblical authority regarding justice for humanity was the law above all else, because he simply loved God.
Most Christians believe in unquestioning obedience to authority, based on New Testament passages such as Romans 13:1–7, Titus 3:1 and 1 Peter 2:13–17, which hold that all governments are either ordained or allowed by God, so Christians should obey them.
But what if that government is unjust? What if that government is established on genocide? What if those authorities are denying poor and powerless people human rights and dignity? Should Christians who have a mandate from God to disobey unjust authority and laws from Scriptures like Daniel 3, the entire book of Esther (which is particularly relevant today as Esther risked her own life to save her people from a planned genocide, but Christians today sit mostly silent as Israel carries out genocide against Palestinians because, again, they believe terrible falsehoods perpetrated in the name of God that are not biblical at all), and Acts 5:29 ignore those instructions and obey evil authority?
This is not what John Brown did. He knew the same Scriptures; still, he chose to break federal law (the Fugitive Slave Act) to free enslaved people, believing God’s divine law of the equality of all men superseded human law that relegated Africans and their progeny to subhuman, livestock status.
Today, Christians who believe in justice, equality, human rights and dignity for all people — regardless of race, gender, gender identity, “legal or citizenship status,” or any other disqualifier we might want to deflect our advocacy over — can and should engage in far more protest and acts of civil disobedience to defend that belief and realize that ideal than many do now. But as even Frederick Douglass had to admit after John Brown’s execution, there might come a point at which defending the lives of the oppressed will require armed struggle when those who oppress them ignore peaceful, personal and even political appeals, and continue to impose unconscionable violence upon the people, especially those who openly oppose them.
Jacqueline Luqman is a broadcaster, activist and writer who explores faith, politics and liberation through a radical Black internationalist lens. Host of the weekly radio show Darker Than Blue on the Pacifica Network’s WPFW 89.3 FM and a political commentator on the Black Liberation Media YouTube platform, she draws on decades of activism and scholarship to challenge injustice and inspire Christians to embrace a faith that resists oppression. She lives in Washington, D.C. This column is adapted from her new book, We Need John Brown Christians, and is excerpted here by permission of Broadleaf Books.


