Baptist News Global
Sections
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • Curated
  • Storytelling
    • Faith & Justice >
      • Charleston: Metanoia with Bill Stanfield
      • Charlotte: QC Family Tree with Greg and Helms Jarrell
      • Little Rock: Judge Wendell Griffen
      • North Carolina: Conetoe
    • Welcoming the Stranger >
      • Lost Boys of Sudan: St. John’s Baptist Charlotte
      • Awakening to Immigrant Justice: Myers Park Baptist Church
      • Hospitality on the corner: Gaston Christian Center
    • Signature Ministries >
      • Jake Hall: Gospel Gothic, Music and Radio
    • Singing Our Faith >
      • Hymns for a Lifetime: Ken Wilson and Knollwood Baptist Church
      • Norfolk Street Choir
    • Resilient Rural America >
      • Alabama: Perry County
      • Texas: Hidalgo County
      • Arkansas Delta
      • Southeast Kentucky
  • More
    • Contact
    • About
    • Donate
    • Associated Baptist Press Foundation
    • Planned Giving
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Advertising
    • Ministry Jobs and More
    • Transitions
    • Subscribe
    • Submissions and Permissions
Donate Subscribe
Search Search this site

Atonement tweet sparks blood feud on social media

NewsBob Allen  |  March 1, 2017

When it comes to social media, there is power in the blood.

“Questioning penal substitutionary atonement really brings out the 30-year-old white dudes in my feed,” contemporary Christian musician Michael Gungor commented during a Twitter storm he started Feb. 25 with the recommendation: “I would love to hear more artists who sing to God and fewer who include a Father murdering a son in that endeavor.”

Penal substitution is a notion developed during the Reformation that Christ died on the cross as a substitute for sinners, bearing the wrath of a righteous God. Promoted by the likes of John Calvin and Billy Graham, it was long the default position in Western Christianity but in recent decades has come under challenge from theologians who regard it divine child abuse.

 

Michael and Lisa Gungor are curators of the Grammy-nominated musical collective simply known as Gungor. Gungor recently released the third in a trilogy of “One Wild Life” albums describing their experiences since the release of their album “I Am Mountain” in 2013. (Gungormusic.com)

“If you can’t think of anything to sing to God other than gratitude for taking your shame away through bloodshed, stop singing and look around,” Gungor said in a follow-up tweet.

Engaging online critics, the singer/songwriter who leads the Grammy-nominated musical collective Gungor said he didn’t “mean to minimize the meaning and symbolism of the cross for billions of Christians through the centuries.”

“I simply think blood sacrifice is a very limited and less than timely metaphor for what the cross can mean in our culture,” the Los Angeles-based entertainer revisited the topic the day after the original post.

“People used to slaughter animals to appease the wrath of the gods. Early Christians used the story of the cross to show how the blood sacrifice idea was unnecessary,” Gungor said. “Jesus was the ‘ultimate sacrifice.’ They could stop trying to get to God with violence.”

In proper context, Gungor said describing the cross as a blood sacrifice “is a beautiful metaphor.”

“To see it as literal and out of context — that God needed to be appeased with blood — is not beautiful,” he added. “It’s horrific.”

Owen Strachan, associate professor of Christian theology at Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary in Kansas City, Mo., took exception to Gungor’s argument in a Patheos blog Feb. 27.

“Gungor may think he is preserving a pristine and beautiful God by removing blood atonement from the equation,” Strachan said. “But in truth, Gungor’s move to sanitize God reworks the holy character of the divine, making God a less-than-holy figure, and leaves sinners without any of the benefits of the death of Christ.”

Owen Strachan

“Without Christ, we have none of the righteousness of Christ, no redemption by his work, no propitiation of divine wrath, no sonship in the Son, no reconciliation with God, no reconciliation with fellow blood-bought sinners, and no victory over Satan, sin, death, and hell,” Strachan expounded.

“A Christ who does not give his life as a ransom for sin (Mark 10:45) is a Christ of good feelings, a Christ of emotional solidarity with sinners, a Christ who feels positively toward the lost, but who does nothing to redeem them,” Strachan said.

Gungor is no stranger to theological controversy. In 2014 he and his wife, Lisa, roiled the contemporary Christian music scene by saying they didn’t take the Genesis accounts of creation and Noah’s flood literally.

He also isn’t the first Christian musician to face controversy over the atonement. In 2013 the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) dropped plans to include the hymn “In Christ Alone” in a new hymnal after authors Keith and Kristyn Getty refused permission to alter the phrase “as Jesus died/the wrath of God was satisfied” to “Till on that cross as Jesus died/the love of God was magnified.”

The Atonement, the term used to describe the sacrificial work of Jesus for sinners, is a central doctrine in Christianity, but theologians have long debated what it means.

Frank Stagg, a longtime professor at both New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary and Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Ky., rejected the propositional concept of substitutionary atonement in a 1951 paper, “The Rationale of the Cross.”

“The aim of the cross is reconciliation and forgiveness,” Stagg said in an excerpt quoted in a collection of essays honoring his work published in 1985 by Mercer University Press.

“These are creative,” Stagg wrote. “The aim is to effect a transformation in us. God’s way of Jesus confronts man; man is condemned, he fears and hates so he tries to destroy Jesus; but in this encounter man may be converted by Him who utterly refused to act for Himself — by Him who gave even his life.”

Fisher Humphries

Fisher Humphreys, who taught at both New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary and Beeson Divinity School before his retirement in 2008, offered an alternative to penal substitution called “cruciform forgiveness” in a 1978 book titled The Death of Christ published by Southern Baptist publisher Broadman Press.

Humphreys’ suggestion that Christ’s death was salvific but not theologically necessary became an undercurrent in the inerrancy controversy that divided the Southern Baptist Convention at the end of the 20th century.

“The atonement was, in fact, necessary in order to fulfill the Scriptures,” conservative resurgence co-founder Paige Patterson said in a 2011 essay looking back on his debate with Humphreys about the book held on the campus of New Orleans Seminary in 1987.

Today the atonement debate in the nation’s second-largest faith group behind Roman Catholics is over the purpose of Christ’s death.

Limited atonement, one of the five points of Calvinism, holds that Christ’s death was intended to secure redemption for only the “elect,” those whom God has predetermined to save.

“I think that of all the five points of Calvinism, limited atonement is the most controversial, and the one that engenders perhaps the most confusion and consternation,” Ligonier Ministries founder R.C. Sproul wrote in an article published in 2012.

Sproul, a member of the Calvinist Presbyterian Church in America, said he prefers the term “definite” atonement or redemption to communicate “that God the Father designed the work of redemption specifically with a view to providing salvation for the elect, and that Christ died for His sheep and laid down His life for those the Father had given to Him.”

A Statement of the Traditional Southern Baptist Understanding of God’s Plan of Salvation, posted online by Connect316, a group formed to counterbalance organizations promoting Calvinism in the SBC, affirms penal substitution but denies “that Christ died only for the sins of those who will be saved.”

Previous stories:

Contemporary Christian musician under fire for doubting Genesis

SBC leader says Gungor trusts science more than the Bible

Wrath of God verse roils hymnal group

Editorial ignites atonement debate

Rethinking the atonement

Tags:Atonementsubstitutionary atonementMichael Gungor
More by
Bob Allen
  • Get BNG headlines in your inbox

  • Featured

    • The fantastical world of climate change denial: Slouching toward annihilation

      Opinion

    • Veterans and faith groups urge Congress to secure the safety of Afghan immigrants

      News

    • Frederick Buechner influenced millions with his insightful writing and quotable lines

      News

    • Remembering a sign for the times: The serpent and the seminary

      Opinion


    Curated

    • In latest ‘gOD-Talk’ discussion, Black millennials discuss hip-hop and faith

      In latest ‘gOD-Talk’ discussion, Black millennials discuss hip-hop and faith

      August 16, 2022
    • Colorado to spar over discrimination case in Supreme Court

      Colorado to spar over discrimination case in Supreme Court

      August 16, 2022
    • Crossing the rubicon? Mar-a-Lago raid enflames right wing fantasies of Christian Caesarism

      Crossing the rubicon? Mar-a-Lago raid enflames right wing fantasies of Christian Caesarism

      August 16, 2022
    • An interfaith discussion on the role of religion in mental health

      An interfaith discussion on the role of religion in mental health

      August 16, 2022
    Read Next:

    No, Dan Patrick, God did not write the U.S. Constitution

    OpinionRick Pidcock

    More Articles

    • All
    • News
    • Opinion
    • Curated
    • Ministry jobs and more

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • Hymn stories: ‘The Church’s One Foundation’

      OpinionBeverly A. Howard

    • Veterans and faith groups urge Congress to secure the safety of Afghan immigrants

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • The fantastical world of climate change denial: Slouching toward annihilation

      OpinionRodney Kennedy

    • When forced to choose between their ministry and their transgender child, this family chose love

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Remembering a sign for the times: The serpent and the seminary

      OpinionDalen Jackson

    • Frederick Buechner influenced millions with his insightful writing and quotable lines

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • No, Dan Patrick, God did not write the U.S. Constitution

      OpinionRick Pidcock

    • Black religion and reparation questions

      OpinionWendell Griffen

    • Progressive National Convention joins with AFL-CIO to advance racial and economic justice

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • What happened to American conservatism? Engaging Matthew Continetti’s The Right

      OpinionDavid Gushee, Senior Columnist

    • Historic Kentucky church calls gay man as co-pastor

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Department of Justice investigating SBC on sexual abuse

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • ‘Everything is changing at the same time,’ veteran religion reporter explains

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Skepticism holds seeds of hope: The SBC and clergy sex abuse

      OpinionChrista Brown

    • Tony and Lauren Dungy know something about influence, on the field and at home

      NewsMaina Mwaura

    • Here’s what I’m learning in therapy

      OpinionMark Wingfield

    • Letter to the Editor: I also stand with Brittney Griner and kneel for the Anthem

      OpinionLetters to the Editor

    • It’s easier to be a bully today, author explains

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • A thoughtful question at Bubba-Doo’s

      OpinionCharles Qualls

    • When conservatives today speak of ‘states’ rights,’ they likely don’t mean the popular vote; here’s a case in point

      AnalysisMark Wingfield

    • Transitions for the week of 8-12-22

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • SBC president says he tried to enlist more women for sexual abuse task force but got turned down repeatedly

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • At long last, Trump’s ‘Remain in Mexico’ policy appears to be dead

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • In applauding Victor Orban, U.S. conservatives call their shot

      OpinionRodney Kennedy

    • Ministry jobs and more

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • Veterans and faith groups urge Congress to secure the safety of Afghan immigrants

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • When forced to choose between their ministry and their transgender child, this family chose love

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Frederick Buechner influenced millions with his insightful writing and quotable lines

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Progressive National Convention joins with AFL-CIO to advance racial and economic justice

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Historic Kentucky church calls gay man as co-pastor

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Department of Justice investigating SBC on sexual abuse

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • ‘Everything is changing at the same time,’ veteran religion reporter explains

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Tony and Lauren Dungy know something about influence, on the field and at home

      NewsMaina Mwaura

    • It’s easier to be a bully today, author explains

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Transitions for the week of 8-12-22

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • SBC president says he tried to enlist more women for sexual abuse task force but got turned down repeatedly

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • At long last, Trump’s ‘Remain in Mexico’ policy appears to be dead

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Some evangelical leaders see FBI visit to Trump’s Mar-a-Lago as evidence of the religious persecution coming to them

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • New study finds scammers luring migrants with false information via Facebook and WhatsApp

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Progressive Baptist congregation on Wake Forest campus votes to close

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Ministry jobs and more

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • South African women’s soccer team success shines a light on gender wage discrimination

      NewsAnthony Akaeze

    • It isn’t a church and doesn’t have members, but it is a way to keep United Methodists in the fold as their congregations disaffiliate

      NewsCynthia Astle

    • Rural church offers community development grants through Gratitude Project

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • The church needs to do better on monkeypox than it did on HIV, faith leaders say

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Russell Moore named editor in chief of Christianity Today

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • 40 Congressmen urge IRS to reconsider classification of Family Research Council as a ‘church’

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Online religion content isn’t luring Millennials away from in-person church

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Ministry jobs and more

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • Hymn stories: ‘The Church’s One Foundation’

      OpinionBeverly A. Howard

    • The fantastical world of climate change denial: Slouching toward annihilation

      OpinionRodney Kennedy

    • Remembering a sign for the times: The serpent and the seminary

      OpinionDalen Jackson

    • No, Dan Patrick, God did not write the U.S. Constitution

      OpinionRick Pidcock

    • Black religion and reparation questions

      OpinionWendell Griffen

    • What happened to American conservatism? Engaging Matthew Continetti’s The Right

      OpinionDavid Gushee, Senior Columnist

    • Skepticism holds seeds of hope: The SBC and clergy sex abuse

      OpinionChrista Brown

    • Here’s what I’m learning in therapy

      OpinionMark Wingfield

    • Letter to the Editor: I also stand with Brittney Griner and kneel for the Anthem

      OpinionLetters to the Editor

    • A thoughtful question at Bubba-Doo’s

      OpinionCharles Qualls

    • In applauding Victor Orban, U.S. conservatives call their shot

      OpinionRodney Kennedy

    • Christian nationalism is a danger to our nation

      OpinionMarvin McMickle

    • Advice from a sunflower

      OpinionPhawnda Moore

    • What I learned at Wake Forest Baptist Church

      OpinionDavid Ramsey

    • Why can’t we accept sexual and gender diversity in humans as well as in all creation?

      OpinionDan McGee

    • I’ve been unaware of my privilege, and if you are a man, you probably have, too

      OpinionRobert P. Sellers

    • Are left-wing radicals pushing Cracker Barrel to the edge of the slippery slope?

      OpinionBrett Younger

    • To be more welcoming, let’s remove our flags

      OpinionJustin Pierson

    • News flash: Not all Baptists are Southern

      OpinionBrian Kaylor

    • Why aren’t we defending Brittney Griner?

      OpinionRodney Kennedy

    • A school administrator reflects on rebuilding relationships between schools and homes

      OpinionStanton Eugene Lawrence

    • Judging the stripper and the carouser in ourselves at the Communion table

      OpinionBrad Bull

    • After the Guidepost report, we need to know more about FBC Woodstock’s City of Refuge and NAMB’s support for it: Was ‘moral failures’ code for sexual abuse?

      OpinionJoanna Sullivan

    • Forsaking Baal for the God who is in recovery

      OpinionBill Leonard, Senior Columnist

    • Thomas Merton, Martin Luther King and Critical Race Theory

      OpinionKen Zagacki

    • In latest ‘gOD-Talk’ discussion, Black millennials discuss hip-hop and faith

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Colorado to spar over discrimination case in Supreme Court

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Crossing the rubicon? Mar-a-Lago raid enflames right wing fantasies of Christian Caesarism

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • An interfaith discussion on the role of religion in mental health

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Republicans keep mostly mum on calls to make GOP ‘party of Christian nationalism’

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • The Faith-Based Politics of El Salvador’s Millennial President

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Reckoning with their history, Lutherans issue declaration to Indigenous peoples

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Religion, Spirituality Second Most Frequently Read Genre in U.S.

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Pope Francis meets transgender guests of Rome church

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Politicians seek to control classroom discussions about slavery in the US

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Despite vastly different values, evangelical ‘Hamilton’ connects secular left and Christian right

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Both Open- and Close-mindedness Increase in U.S.

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Native Americans urge boycott of ‘tone deaf’ Pilgrim museum

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Boston’s Jews are getting a ‘Jewish tavern’ to study religious text — and drink beer

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • ReAwaken Tour host says he feels harassed by NY prosecutor

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Why the largest US Lutheran denomination apologized to a Latino congregation

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • The Supreme Court Wants to End the Separation of Church and State

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Suspect in Dallas salon May shooting indicted for anti-Asian hate crime

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Anglican Division over Scripture and Sexuality Heads South

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Amy Spitalnick, who took on neo-Nazis in Charlottesville, is moving to Bend the Arc

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • New York City’s Largest Evangelical Church Plans Billion-Dollar Development

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Ben & Jerry’s fears its new Israeli owner could sell ‘Judea and Samaria’ ice cream in latest court hearing

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Why Alexander Hamilton gave his heart to Jesus at a Texas church this weekend

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Baby Blues: How to Face the Church’s Growing Fertility Crisis

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Orthodox Alaska Part 2: The Beatles, Bees And Orthodoxy Animated In One Man’s Life

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    Conversations that Matter.

    © 2022 Baptist News Global. All rights reserved.

    Want to share a story? We hope you will! Read our republishing, terms of use and privacy policies here.

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS