When Southern Baptists met in Anaheim, Calif., in 2022, leaders apologized to abuse survivors and took first steps toward creating a database of accused offenders. Four years later, the Houston Chronicle reported in June that abuse reform was barely mentioned at the convention’s 2026 Orlando meeting and the promised database never has materialized.
An Executive Committee spokesman said leaders still encourage churches to use existing databases of convicted offenders available through background-check providers.
Whatever one thinks of the convention’s choices, that last sentence lands the responsibility exactly where Baptist polity always has put it: On the local church. Every Baptist congregation, Southern Baptist or not, now needs its own church volunteer screening policy, adopted by the congregation and actually followed.
Congregational autonomy is not an excuse for waiting. It is the reason we cannot wait.
Autonomy cuts both ways
Baptists have long defended the freedom of each congregation to call its own pastors, govern its own affairs and answer to no hierarchy but Christ. That freedom is real, and it comes with a matching burden. No bishop will audit our nursery. No denominational office will check who teaches our fifth grade boys.
If a congregation does not decide how it protects children and vulnerable adults, nobody else will.
I have worked in background screening for about 15 years, and I have watched small churches stall on this for familiar reasons: Cost, confusing consent paperwork and a fear of offending long-time members.
“If a congregation does not decide how it protects children and vulnerable adults, nobody else will.”
Those are understandable. They are not reasons to leave the door open.
What a database never could have done
It is worth being honest about the limits of what Baptists were promised. A list of credibly accused ministers would have helped churches avoid calling a known offender to the pulpit or church staff. It would not have screened the volunteer who drives the youth van, the new member who offers to help in children’s church or the deacon’s friend who wants to chaperone camp.
Those decisions always were going to be made in the church office, by people who know the names.
Background checks, too, have limits. A criminal check finds convictions and some pending charges. Much abuse is never reported or prosecuted, so a clean report means only that nothing reportable surfaced.
That is why screening has to be one part of a wider standard.
A minimum church volunteer screening policy any congregation can adopt
Here is a floor, not a ceiling. Any church can vote it in at its next business meeting.
- Adopt it as a congregation. Put the policy to a congregational vote, so it carries the church’s authority and survives turnover in staff and committees.
- Screen everyone who works with minors or vulnerable adults. That means a written application, references and a criminal background check, plus a search of the free National Sex Offender Public Website. If the church uses a screening company, federal law requires a stand-alone written disclosure and the volunteer’s written authorization before the check and specific notices before and after any decision based on it. Screen staff and pastors to the same standard. No exceptions for tenure or title.
- Call references, including previous churches. Ask former churches directly whether there ever were concerns about the person’s conduct with children. Write down the answers.
- Set a waiting period. Require new members to attend for a set time, commonly six months, before serving with children. People who intend harm look for churches that let them start immediately.
- Never one adult alone with a child. Two unrelated adults in every classroom, every vehicle and every overnight room. Windows in doors. No private messaging with minors.
- Train and report. Teach every volunteer to recognize grooming and to report suspected abuse to civil authorities, as state law requires, not just to the pastor. Make clear that reporting is not disloyalty.
- Re-screen on a schedule. A check from 2019 tells you little about 2026. Repeat checks every two or three years, and ask volunteers to disclose new charges in between.
The CDC’s guidance on preventing child sexual abuse in youth-serving organizations describes the same structure: Screening, rules for interactions, monitoring, safe environments, responding to concerns and training. None of it requires a denomination to act first.
Tell the truth when someone leaves
There is one more piece that only churches can supply. When a staff member or volunteer leaves amid credible concerns, the next church deserves to know. Too many abusers have moved from congregation to congregation because a reference letter said only that they “served faithfully.”
“The autonomy of the next congregation depends on our honesty.”
Talk with an attorney about how to share facts responsibly, but do not stay silent to avoid awkwardness. The autonomy of the next congregation depends on our honesty.
Associations can help without overriding anyone
Small congregations do not have to do this alone. Local Baptist associations and regional fellowships can share what they already do well: a common training night for children’s workers, a sample policy any church may adopt or amend, a list of reputable screening providers, a trusted attorney to call.
None of that infringes on autonomy. It simply means no church of 40 members has to invent child protection from scratch, and no church can claim it did not know where to start.
The work is ours
Baptists can and will keep arguing about what conventions and associations should do. Those arguments matter. But no vote in a convention hall will screen the volunteers in your children’s wing this Sunday.
That always has been the local church’s job. For congregations that want a head start, this church ministry safety toolkit gathers free policies and forms, and this piece on church safety controls that only exist on paper is a useful self-check.
Our polity gives every congregation the freedom to do this well. It is time we used it.
Matt Angerer is the founder of ScreenForge Labs, the FCRA-regulated consumer reporting agency behind VolunteerBadge. He has spent about 15 years in background screening: in 2011 he co-founded VerticalRent, which has run more than 1 million FCRA-compliant background checks for 100,000 landlords. Matt also hosts “The Sign-In Table,” a podcast of conversations with the nonprofit leaders who run volunteer programs.


