Former Christian music star Michael Passons left the popular band Avalon in 2003 not of his own volition, but after his fellow bandmates pressured him to do so.
Passons, who is openly gay, was closeted at the time and that was the reason for his ouster from the band. But his fellow bandmates told CCM magazine it was his own choice to leave Avalon.
“It was definitely something that created PTSD for me, and I spent many years dealing with the trauma and the pain and the humiliation and all that goes with losing your career in a single second,” Passons says in a new documentary, titled Safe for the Whole Family.
Two of those former bandmates have since reconnected with Passons and acknowledged in Safe for the Whole Family that his recollection of events is true, and they regret how they treated him 23 years ago.
Passons is just one of several former contemporary Christian music stars who are telling their full stories in the documentary directed by Jason Ikeler, who recently showed the film at the Nashville Film Festival and Virginia Film Festival. It’s scheduled to be released winter 2027.
The documentary is part of a deeper reckoning in recent years with 1990s and 2000s evangelical Christian culture and media, and the harms it caused promoters and consumers alike.
“One of the conversations I had with every artist early on is, ‘I just want to tell the truth; I don’t want this to be a take-down of Christianity or religion,’” Ikeler told Baptist News Global. “I just want this to be, ‘These are real people, this is what happened to them.’”
Ikeler’s inspiration to make the film is partly personal. Growing up in a Free Methodist household and a listener of contemporary Christian music, Ikeler later came out as gay and moved away from home and became a videographer.
When he came out, it was around the same time Christian singer-songwriter Jennifer Knapp had come out as lesbian, famously on Larry King Live in 2010. At the time, the news was one of the biggest scandals in the Christian music world following Amy Grant’s divorce from her first husband, Gary Chapman, in 1999.
“Pop artists and the pop end of contemporary Christian music is where evangelical media makers and consumers put all their hopes and dreams for the adolescent evangelical young people they served in this market,” said Leah Payne, a religious historian based in Oregon. “Because contemporary Christian music served as a way of promoting idealized forms of evangelical adolescence, a ton of the songs, the political activism, the preaching and the youth group activities centered around regulating evangelical sexuality for young people.”
Payne’s 2024 book God Gave Rock and Roll to You: A History of Contemporary Christian Music is one of the first comprehensive examinations of the industry, which she said was valued at $1 billion at its height.
In addition to Passons and Knapp, Safe for the Whole Family looks at the story of Nikki Leonti, who became a Christian music star at the age of 15. At the age of 18, she became pregnant and disappeared from stardom before returning for a public apology tour. The professional upheaval she experienced and the personal tumult of an allegedly abusive marriage with her first husband, former Christian rock musician Ryan Gingerich, ultimately led to her disillusionment with evangelicalism and departure from Christian music. Gingerich’s attorney denied Leonti’s allegations of abuse in a statement for the documentary.
The documentary doesn’t get into the biggest scandal lately in Christian music, which is the flood of sexual abuse allegations against former Newsboys frontman Michael Tait. Ikeler said that’s partly a matter of timing. Also, he said the film’s focus is “the people who got pushed out, not the people the industry was helping to protect.”
The pressures on Passons and Knapp to stay closeted or on Leonti after she became pregnant were directly related to the industry’s bottom line, Ikeler and Payne said. “The main customer and consumer of a Christian bookstore was a white suburban Christian mom. So, it was this idea of, ‘We know your kids want this secular music, here’s a Christian replica.’”
One example cited in the documentary is Trin-i-Tee 5:7, or the Christian music equivalent of Destiny’s Child — the girl group that famously made Beyoncé a star. Former Trin-i-Tee 5:7 performer Chanelle Haynes talks about a song called “My Body.”
“The song is all about purity and is saying, ‘Don’t mess with me. I’m God’s property.’ And if you love me, you’ll wait until you’re married to have sex,’” Haynes explains in the documentary.
This particular era of Christian music stardom is over, largely due to the decline of Christian booksellers and Lifeway’s closure of brick-and-mortar shops. The genre is still making money, just in different forms.
If it were to still exist in that earlier form, “then we would see a contemporary Christian music version of K-Pop or Bad Bunny,” Payne said. “Because whatever is the top selling form in mainstream culture, we would see an attempt to create an evangelical version of that. And there isn’t to my knowledge.”
The film’s title derives from a marketing slogan widely used in contemporary Christian radio in the 1990s and 2000s.
Related:
Finally, an honest conversation about CCM and Gospel music | Analysis by Rick Pidcock
Newsboys lawsuit exposes underlying finances of CCM business | Analysis by Rick Pidcock
New history sees CCM as a ‘soundtrack’ for white evangelicalism | Analysis by Steve Rabey


