Baptist News Global
Sections
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • Curated
  • Storytelling
    • Faith & Justice >
      • Charleston: Metanoia with Bill Stanfield
      • Charlotte: QC Family Tree with Greg and Helms Jarrell
      • Little Rock: Judge Wendell Griffen
      • North Carolina: Conetoe
    • Welcoming the Stranger >
      • Lost Boys of Sudan: St. John’s Baptist Charlotte
      • Awakening to Immigrant Justice: Myers Park Baptist Church
      • Hospitality on the corner: Gaston Christian Center
    • Signature Ministries >
      • Jake Hall: Gospel Gothic, Music and Radio
    • Singing Our Faith >
      • Hymns for a Lifetime: Ken Wilson and Knollwood Baptist Church
      • Norfolk Street Choir
    • Resilient Rural America >
      • Alabama: Perry County
      • Texas: Hidalgo County
      • Arkansas Delta
      • Southeast Kentucky
  • More
    • Contact
    • About
    • Donate
    • Associated Baptist Press Foundation
    • Planned Giving
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Advertising
    • Ministry Jobs and More
    • Transitions
    • Subscribe
    • Submissions and Permissions
Donate Subscribe
Search Search this site
Featured
Featured

Hoping for cessation of ‘war on Christmas’ rhetoric? Don’t, historians say

NewsJeff Brumley  |  December 13, 2016

Another season of the so-called “war on Christmas,” especially in the wake of Donald Trump’s election, may be just enough to drive some people over the edge.

And all indications are it isn’t going to go away.

Thomas Kidd

Thomas Kidd

“There is no easier way for politicians or pundits to rally the base this time of year than hyping the ‘War on Christmas’ by liberal elites,” Baylor University history professor Thomas Kidd said in a book review of Gerry Bowler’s Christmas in the Crosshairs: Two Thousand Years of Denouncing and Defending the World’s Most Celebrated Holiday.

“Donald Trump’s son Eric told evangelist James Robison in an August interview that one reason Trump decided to run for president was because the White House ‘Christmas tree’ was now called the “holiday tree,’” Kidd writes, adding that multiple sources say the change never occurred.

In his Christianity Today piece, Kidd presents Bowler’s account of the love-hate affair some Christians have had toward Christianity through the centuries.

Religion scholars are not surprised conservative evangelicals herald the holiday today, when their Puritan ancestors banned it for being too Catholic and pagan. And they have taken just about every position in-between.

But what is consistent is the battle, said Andrew Gardner, a doctoral student in American religious history and author of the 2015 book Reimaging Zion: A History of the Alliance of Baptists.

“There is nothing new under the sun,” Gardner told Baptist News Global. “That reminds me that we’re constantly undergoing a negotiation as to what Christmas means.”

The constant back-and-forth, Gardner said, is about the symbols inherent in Christmas.

“Anytime you’re dealing with symbols you’re constantly negotiating over what they mean.”

For some, Christmas symbolizes the incarnation. For others, it’s about decorated trees and time for family. For some, it’s time off from work and gift-giving. While others see it as a sign of their faith’s place in the culture.

Other issues that have shared that kind of back-and-forth are Ten Commandments and prayer in school debates, Gardner said.

“Another example is communion and what communion means, and Baptists in particular do that a lot,” he said.

From Puritans to Westboro Baptist

puritanchristmasbanThe Christmas tug-of-war began early, Kidd writes in his review of Bowler’s book, which was published in October by Oxford University Press

Some early Protestants saw the holiday negatively because it was tied to the Catholic Church. They believed it to be Rome’s attempt to Christianize a pagan festival.

“In the 1640s, the Puritan-dominated English Parliament banned Christmas. …’” Kidd writes.

The holiday’s prospects improved around the early 19th century with the works of Charles Dickens and others. The 1822 publication of a story known as “’Twas the Night Before Christmas” is also considered a pivotal moment, Kidd writes.

“The gift-giving Santa also transformed Christmas into the merchants’ holiday par excellence,” he added.

The book also provides modern examples of the tug-of-war over Christmas. These include Westboro Baptist’s replacement of “Santa Claus is comin’ to Town” with “Santa Claus Will Take You to Hell.” Planned Parenthood, Bowler reported, offered a version of the “Twelve Days of Christmas” in which a lover offers family-planning gifts to his beloved.

And there are ACLU and other secularists’ efforts to remove Christmas symbols from the public square.

Bowler is opposed to both of the spectrum in the ongoing culture battle, according to Kidd.

Part of the problem, Gardner added, is that Christmas has become a secular, national holiday. That makes the debate over its meaning particularly complex.

“Any time you have something this fluid and this malleable, you’re always going to go through this negotiating,” Gardner said.

And for that reason, there is little hope the rhetoric is going to stop.

“In 10 to 15 years it may not be about Christmas, but it will be about other things,” he said.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)
Tags:War on ChristmasEric TrumpPlanned ParenthoodJames RobinsonWestboro Baptist ChurchZionTen CommandmentsFlorida State UniversityCommunionCharles DickensBaylor UniversityChristianityAlliance of BaptistsPuritansDonald TrumpACLUBaptist News Globalprayer in schoolCatholic ChurchGerry BowlerPaganismThomas Kidd
More by
Jeff Brumley
Read Next:

Karen Swallow Prior to leave Southeastern Seminary

NewsMark Wingfield

More Articles

  • All
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Curated
  • One-third of Northern Seminary students express no confidence in trustees

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • He was wrongly put on Death Row and believes you could be too

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • If a story is meant to evolve, then so are we

    OpinionKaitlin Curtice

  • Paula Faris makes a case for motherhood

    NewsMaina Mwaura

  • Sociologists find LGBTQ United Methodists, allies stay in UMC out of hope

    NewsCynthia Astle

  • Angels among us

    OpinionMary Alice Birdwhistell

  • Let’s stop treating the dignity of women as a secondary issue good Christians can disagree on

    OpinionRick Pidcock

  • First American woman appointed a missionary beat the system by funding herself

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • An Anglican in Babylon

    OpinionLee Enochs

  • Jimmy Carter leads by example one last time

    NewsMallory Challis

  • Listen to the voices of women

    OpinionKathy Manis Findley

  • Ministry jobs and more

    NewsBarbara Francis

  • Karen Swallow Prior to leave Southeastern Seminary

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • Acting chair of Northern Seminary board resigns in protest of board’s ‘official silence’ about Shiell

    NewsElizabeth Souder

  • This Women’s History Month, complementarianism is trending on TikTok

    AnalysisMallory Challis

  • Stranger in the Village: James Baldwin and inclusion

    OpinionGreg Garrett, Senior Columnist

  • Amid rampant antisemitism, most Americans think highly of Jews 

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • How can we say thanks? Reflections on the influence of Andrae Crouch

    OpinionDoug Haney

  • Two days after filing suit against SBC, ‘Pastor Johnny’ was preaching in Georgia

    NewsMaina Mwaura

  • ‘Pastor Johnny’ sues the SBC and Guidepost

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • Eating disorders in religious communities: The benefits, and consequences, of assigning moral value to food

    AnalysisMallory Challis

  • UMC agency asks to monitor bishop’s case as suspicion rises

    NewsCynthia Astle

  • Polling is shifting on conservatives’ attitudes on immigration

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • The SBC: ‘They are who we thought they were’

    OpinionKris Aaron

  • Denny Burk pushes back against Rick Warren’s new understanding of women in ministry

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • One-third of Northern Seminary students express no confidence in trustees

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • He was wrongly put on Death Row and believes you could be too

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • Paula Faris makes a case for motherhood

    NewsMaina Mwaura

  • Sociologists find LGBTQ United Methodists, allies stay in UMC out of hope

    NewsCynthia Astle

  • First American woman appointed a missionary beat the system by funding herself

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • Jimmy Carter leads by example one last time

    NewsMallory Challis

  • Ministry jobs and more

    NewsBarbara Francis

  • Karen Swallow Prior to leave Southeastern Seminary

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • Acting chair of Northern Seminary board resigns in protest of board’s ‘official silence’ about Shiell

    NewsElizabeth Souder

  • Amid rampant antisemitism, most Americans think highly of Jews 

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • Two days after filing suit against SBC, ‘Pastor Johnny’ was preaching in Georgia

    NewsMaina Mwaura

  • ‘Pastor Johnny’ sues the SBC and Guidepost

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • UMC agency asks to monitor bishop’s case as suspicion rises

    NewsCynthia Astle

  • Polling is shifting on conservatives’ attitudes on immigration

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • Denny Burk pushes back against Rick Warren’s new understanding of women in ministry

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • Akin apologizes for tweet about slavery but is chastised by the SBC’s far-right

    NewsMark Wingfield

  • 80,000 Jews have fled Russia since Putin invaded Ukraine

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • Africa’s freelance prophets are breaking free of denominations

    NewsNyasha Bhobo

  • Transitions for the week of 3-17-23

    NewsBarbara Francis

  • CeCe Winans believes it

    NewsMaina Mwaura

  • BSK seeks input on youth and children’s ministries

    NewsPat Cole

  • Alliance of Baptists and others urge Congress to divert military funds to social services

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • Less talked about: Clergy sexual abuse on the mission field

    NewsDegracias Kalimo

  • Stimpson pours lifetime of skill, compassion into Welcome House refugees

    NewsMarv Knox

  • Inflammatory language of Christian nationalism is a real threat, Hollman and Tyler say

    NewsJeff Brumley

  • If a story is meant to evolve, then so are we

    OpinionKaitlin Curtice

  • Angels among us

    OpinionMary Alice Birdwhistell

  • Let’s stop treating the dignity of women as a secondary issue good Christians can disagree on

    OpinionRick Pidcock

  • An Anglican in Babylon

    OpinionLee Enochs

  • Listen to the voices of women

    OpinionKathy Manis Findley

  • Stranger in the Village: James Baldwin and inclusion

    OpinionGreg Garrett, Senior Columnist

  • How can we say thanks? Reflections on the influence of Andrae Crouch

    OpinionDoug Haney

  • The SBC: ‘They are who we thought they were’

    OpinionKris Aaron

  • Blowing the whistle on wedding fouls

    OpinionBrad Bull

  • ‘Grandmas make the best banana bread’

    OpinionJustin Cox

  • Troubling the water, a gospel for the ‘unmet’

    OpinionBill Leonard, Senior Columnist

  • What has happened to suspended UMC Latina bishop?

    OpinionCynthia Astle

  • When we can’t hear our children’s cries

    OpinionSusan K. Smith

  • How I realized I had been shaped by patriarchal views of pastors

    OpinionTambi Brown Swiney

  • My home state is no longer safe for my family

    OpinionLucas Land

  • Saying the quiet part out loud

    OpinionLindsay Bergstrom

  • Tennessee representative who proposed execution by ‘hanging by a tree’ needs a history lesson

    OpinionRodney Kennedy

  • Letter to the Editor: Call out leaders’ bad behavior

    OpinionLetters to the Editor

  • Three years ago today, our world changed

    OpinionMolly Brummett Wudel

  • Sometimes it’s not a good idea to quote the Bible

    OpinionMark Wingfield

  • Shelter from the storm: The Asbury revival as Woodstock 2.0

    OpinionAlan Bean

  • Lessons from a Hindu wedding: What if the point of evangelism is friendship?

    OpinionSusan M. Shaw, Senior Columnist

  • Paved A Way: Why we need to relearn the history of infrastructure

    OpinionCollin Yarbrough

  • The one thing that unites the world’s religions

    OpinionRobert P. Sellers

  • The rest we must have

    OpinionLaura Stephens-Reed

  • Israel’s Reform rabbi and legislator on judicial overhaul: ‘It doesn’t look good.’

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Israel, Palestinians pledge moves to curb violence ahead of Ramadan

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Pope promotes ‘humanitarian corridors’ for asylum-seekers

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Tim Keller and Beth Moore, On and Off the Stage

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Alarmed by their country’s political direction, more Israelis are seeking to move abroad

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • 2nd Vatican official says pope OK’d ransom payments for nun

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Across the country, a push to observe Muslim holidays in school calendars

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Far-right Israeli minister finds enemy in JDC, the mainstream American Jewish aid group

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Charter school movement divided over religious Oklahoma proposal

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Racial Justice Leaders Are Calling For An End To Deadly Traffic Stops

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Russian Christians Make Theological Case for Peace

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Preemptive Love Coalition to merge with Search for Common Ground

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Buddhism Went Mainstream Decades Ago. US Churches Still Aren’t Ready.

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • AR-15 lapel pins are more than political provocation — they’re symbols of the violence at the heart of white Christian nationalism

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • US tribes get bison as they seek to restore bond with animal

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Tennessee’s drag ban rehashes old culture war narratives

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • US Hispanic Protestant churches are young, growing and largely new to the country

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Pope Francis’ Decade of Division

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • For American Zionist LGBTQ group, Israel’s right-wing government has created an urgent crisis

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Bizarre Tweet About Girls’ Bathrooms Backfires On Oklahoma Education Czar

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • How A Faithful Catholic In Congress Turned Into A Heretic

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Trump vs. DeSantis: Florida pastors mull conservative issues

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • Far-right Israeli minister urges loyalty as his US visit draws protests, boycotts and arrests

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • I went to CPAC to take MAGA supporters’ pulse – China and transgender people are among the top ‘demons’ they say are ruining the country

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

  • With Her Newsworthy ‘Firsts,’ Don’t Ignore Religion Angles In Nikki Haley Vs. Donald Trump

    Curated

    Exclude from home pageBNG staff

Conversations that Matter.

© 2023 Baptist News Global. All rights reserved.

Want to share a story? We hope you will! Read our republishing, terms of use and privacy policies here.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS