The 2026 midterms demonstrated that an increasing majority of Americans do not want to live in an authoritarian, right-wing Christian country, said Robert P. Jones, president of Public Religion Research Institute.
“Most Americans support a pluralistic democracy. They don’t want to live in a Christian nationalist world where there’s a hierarchy between Christians and everybody else or between white Christians and everybody else,” Jones said in a post-election webinar discussion with experts on religion and politics.
The “blue wave” that swept Democrats into governorships, statehouses and Congress also confirmed previous research that the divide of the population over Christian nationalism is heavily lopsided, with conservatives decidedly in the minority in the belief that the nation is specially favored by God and should ideally be governed by white conservative Christians.
“However, I should say it has become the majority view of the current Republican Party and it has become the view of two-thirds of white evangelical Protestants, and that’s why the struggle feels the way it does,” Jones said.
A PRRI survey released in February backed up that assessment. It found only a quarter of independents and one-fifths of Democrats to be “adherents” or “sympathizers” of the authoritarian ideology.
But 56% of Republicans said they believe government and society should be run by conservative Christians. White evangelicals (67%) and Hispanic Protestants (54%) were the only religious groups with majorities supportive of Christian nationalism.
The election showed the disproportion to be even more pronounced with Democratic wins in states like Mississippi, Georgia and Texas where white evangelicals voted as expected and most others voted against conservatives, Jones said.
In Texas, for example, Republican U.S. Senate candidate Ken Paxton received 80% of the white evangelical vote in his loss to Democrat James Talarico, which was in line with evangelical voting nationwide (82%). “But here’s what’s notable — if you look at everybody else in Texas that’s not a white evangelical or born-again Christian, 65% (voted) for Talarico.”
Exit polling indicates just how “far out of the mainstream white evangelical voters are compared to the rest of the voters.”
Exit polling indicates just how “far out of the mainstream white evangelical voters are compared to the rest of the voters” in Texas, he added. “They’re really pulling away from all the rest of the voters in the state.”
The midterms also provided evidence that the number of white evangelicals is shrinking. In Texas, for example, they comprise 13% of the population compared to 19% a decade ago. “According to the exit polls, they’re 20% of voters, so they are turning out at rates higher than other Texans, but it’s a shrinking number over time.”
The election also interrupted the nation’s downward slide into a Christian nationalist state, a trend Jones confronted in his latest book, Backslide: Reclaiming a Faith and a Nation After the Christian Turn Against Democracy.
“One way I think about this election is that it did not solve our problems, it did not dissipate those dynamics, but it did pump the brakes on the backsliding. It bought us some time, it bought us some tools and some power to push back on that, both at the state level and at the national level.”
The Election Day success of white progressive Christian candidates will help the left with its traditional struggles with religion, said Eric McDaniel, a government professor at the University of Texas at Austin.
They include Adam Hamilton, founding pastor of a United Methodist megachurch in Kansas whose campaign emphasized biblical values such as compassion, empathy and human decency.
Talarico, the first Texas Democrat elected to the U.S. Senate in more than 30 years, is a Presbyterian seminarian who spoke of love for his opponents and often quoted Scripture during his campaign.
While former Democratic Presidents Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton and Barack Obama also used religious language, the 2026 midterms showed religious talk has reached a whole new level for white progressives, McDaniel said.
“This has opened the door for certain white Democrats to talk about religion in a way that can reach across the aisle, but also not alienate some of the Democrats who are apprehensive about religion because they see it as a marker of intolerance,” he said. “It’s opened the door for those who went secular because they couldn’t stand what they’re hearing in churches, but then also those who have just been wary about religion for a very long time.”

Samuel Perry speaks at the OU Mueum of Natural History for a gathering of CBF Oklahoma (Photo courtesy of CBFO)
The run-up to the election also showed many Americans just how “bizarre” right-wing extremist personalities and beliefs have become, said Samuel Perry, a sociologist at the University of Oklahoma and co-author of Taking America Back for God: Christian Nationalism in the United States.
Among them are Doug Wilson, a Calvinist pastor in Idaho and self-described Christian nationalist who has led prayer services at the Pentagon for Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. He has advocated for repeal of the 19th Amendment, which guarantees the right of women to vote.
PRRI’s American Values Survey released in October found 87% of Americans oppose abolishing the amendment. Perry noted that includes many on the right.
“I think that’s a good thing. I think we want to trumpet that kind of thing from the rooftops because we want to say, ‘Look, these kinds of people, these kinds of very prominent reactionary voices, how out of step are they with what most Americans want?’”
PRRI CEO Melissa Deckman added that the election of Muslim and Michigan Democrat Abdul El-Sayed to the U.S. Senate was a vote for church-state separation because it was a key plank in his campaign.
“There’s a video of course that went viral of someone saying, ‘Will you renounce the Muslim Brotherhood.?’ He did, but he turned it into a lesson on ‘I support the Constitution, I support everyone’s ability to worship how they see fit,’” she said. “That’s something new, especially in contrast to what we’ve seen with Christian nationalism.”
Related:
Hegseth ‘doubles down’ on Christian nationalism with more Doug Wilson
What Christian nationalist pastors in Texas said after midterms | Analysis by Mara Richards Bim
Christian nationalists have a problem with Christ, Perry says




