A South Carolina judge has said he cannot intervene in a case brought by The United Methodist Church against 70 churches disaffiliating and seeking to take their properties with them.
The South Carolina Conference of the UMC went to court seeking an order to compel the dissident churches to comply with terms of disaffiliation in the Book of Discipline, including a well-known provision that churches hold property “in trust” for the denomination and do not own it.
The departing churches wanted to avoid specific terms required for disaffiliation. They argued the UMC “trust clause” does not comply with South Carolina property law and the conference lacked legal standing to sue them.
After previous temporary exit rules expired, some churches attempted to leave using Paragraph 2549 of the Book of Discipline, which deals with closing or separating properties that no longer serve their intended purpose. However, the UMC Judicial Council ruled Paragraph 2549 could not be used by churches trying to exit over theological differences.
On Nov. 13, state Circuit Court Judge Brian M. Gibbons dismissed 70 of the lawsuits. The South Carolina Conference said it intends to appeal the decision to higher courts.
Judge Gibbons cited the ecclesial abstention doctrine as his basis for not ruling on the case. This is a legal concept that secular courts cannot intervene in internal church workings because doing so would violate the First Amendment’s provisions on separation of church and state.
“In each case, the conference seeks a declaration that the local church’s property is held in trust for the UMC, demands invalidation of the local church’s corporate filings and requests other related relief,” the judge wrote. “Each claim depends on the Book of Discipline of The United Methodist Church. … The court concludes that it lacks subject-matter jurisdiction to adjudicate claims that require it to interpret and enforce the Discipline. Furthermore, even if the court had jurisdiction over these suits, the conference’s claims would fail for additional independent reasons including lack of standing and the failure to state claims on which relief could be granted.”
The South Carolina judge’s ruling disagrees with rulings in similar church property lawsuits that have produced mixed results across the United States. U.S. Supreme Court precedent allows states to choose how they handle these cases.
In most states, courts have ruled in favor of the UMC or dismissed lawsuits brought by departing congregations. That includes courts in Alabama, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, North Carolina, Oklahoma and Pennsylvania.
“The conference and its legal counsel are continuing to review the judge’s orders and intend to appeal these rulings, in accordance with South Carolina law,” said a denominational press release Nov. 13. “Our hope remains to bring these matters before the appellate courts, potentially including the South Carolina Supreme Court, at the earliest appropriate opportunity.”
The dismissal order affects the 68 churches included in Exhibit A of the consolidated lawsuit (see below for list), as well as a separate order dismissing the conference’s case against Simpsonville United Methodist Church, The Methodist Church of Simpsonville, and Michael Smith, and one dismissing the case against Duncan Memorial Methodist Church, et al.
(See the orders to dismiss the consolidated churches here, Simpsonville here, and Duncan Memorial here.)
In its release, the South Carolina Conference urged United Methodists to keep their focus on what’s truly important, noting, “While this development is disappointing, we remain committed to faithfully stewarding the responsibilities entrusted to us — and we encourage South Carolina United Methodists to stay focused on our unchanging mission of making disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world,” the UMC statement said.
Related:
Understanding Methodists and the ‘trust clause’ | Analysis by Lovett Weems


