Leaders come in all shapes and sizes, with assorted personalities, expertise and experience. Like sports teams, they can be mediocre, top-tier or somewhere in between.
Leadership, I believe, is always a privilege, never a right. And a little humility goes a long way. Wise leaders understand that leadership is not about throwing their weight around or treating certain tasks as beneath them. While everyone has defined roles for good reason, if you can’t ever empty your own trash can or pitch in where needed, something is wrong.
There’s a certain gravitas to leadership — a weight that comes with administration, integrity and a deep sense of responsibility. If you know, you know.
Advancing the mission is not contrary to valuing, protecting and adequately resourcing the people you lead. Nor should those people be treated merely as instruments to make you look good.
But leadership is hard. Reprogramming computers and reprogramming people are not the same thing. Computers don’t cop attitudes or mistake your kindness for weakness. Reggae legend Buju Banton was onto something when he said, “It is easier to tame an animal than to tame your tongue.”
Leaders rarely get to say exactly what they want, whenever they want. Doing so is not only counterproductive; it can also make a leader appear unstable, unethical or come across as a big ol’ bully. And no one likes a bully.
Leaders can get a bad rap. Most aren’t stealing money, incompetent or difficult to work with. And yet, every environment a leader walks into has its own history, culture and challenges — conditions that leaders have little choice but to painstakingly navigate, which is hardly ever a walk in the park.
“A culture of poor leadership can become an organizational cancer.”
For those who are genuinely trying to do the right things and have the capacity to execute them, I’ve learned the hard way that a culture of poor leadership can become an organizational cancer, with no chemotherapy cocktail to eliminate it. In such an environment, the bar has been set so low, for so long and in so many ways, that it’s become a stuffed animal we cling to at night for comfort. That is perhaps the worst kind of leadership.
I know of an organization that had about $90 million in physical deferred maintenance. Over the course of perhaps 40 years, its buildings had been kept operational, largely because the cash flow needed for upgrades, innovation or new construction wasn’t there. As a result, from one structure to the next, roofing, plumbing, electrical systems and interior spaces and amenities were left unattended. Those responsible apparently convinced themselves that passing the buck was an exercise in wise discernment.
However, plenty of employees and clients would’ve begged to differ. Talk about a corrosive environment. That is precisely what the deferred maintenance of poor leadership produces.
It stifles progress that could happen because difficult but necessary decisions are avoided in favor of placating the status quo. Therefore, even when people and institutions manage to survive, they do little more than exist. They go through the motions and take two steps forward and three steps backward, never coming close to their true potential.
This happens wherever people gather, but it decimates churches in highly specialized ways.
Even with a combination of paid clergy and staff, churches depend heavily on volunteer labor. None can function without it, and this is one of many distinctions between churches and for-profit corporations. Without the devotion of everyday Joes and Janes, churches can accomplish very little. That’s part of their beauty, but it’s also part of what makes greater — not lesser — operational health, safeguards, strategy and an ironclad conviction about what matters most so essential.
Yet some churches function more like small mom-and-pop family businesses than ministries of God committed to upholding clear biblical principles. There’s history between everyone, good or bad. There’s their particular brand of favoritism. There’s passive aggressiveness. And conflict avoidance lingers in the air like the smell of something left in the oven way too long. But our smoke detectors aren’t working.
“This deferred maintenance of godly leadership only compounds over time, often resulting in irrecoverable damage.”
While there are exceptions, I can tell you from experience that church committees often struggle with efficiency, the competency required for the task at hand and a willingness to do what is right — especially when doing what is right may lead to division or hurt feelings. Nevertheless, it is better to face that with God’s support than to face God’s correction for the cowardly pursuit of ease. To whom much is given, much is required.
Churches sometimes embrace a theology of scarcity. They fail to address situations properly the first time, with thoroughness and resolve, because one or more people — perhaps the loudest voices or the most senior person — believe escapism disguised as grace is the high road. This deferred maintenance of godly leadership only compounds over time, often resulting in irrecoverable damage.
Consequently, it can take a church 11 years to accomplish something, whether simple or complex, that could and should have been addressed long ago. Distrust, disunity and toxicity are fostered at alarming rates. Still, God has not given us a spirit of fear. It’s that simple. And yet, it’s not.
We also must let go of ego and invite skilled conversation partners and qualified professionals into certain situations. Doing so can better equip the laity to embrace models of adaptive, decisive leadership tailored to the local body of Christ — the ekklesia, “the called-out ones.” Whatever happens should be done decently and in order. It should be above reproach.
Lifeway Christian Resources’ director of leadership development, Todd Adkins, has commented, “God is a God of systems and order. … Systems are not ungodly or unholy.” Amen and amen! Excellence and faithfulness ought not be mutually exclusive.
James Ellis III is an ordained Baptist pastor and assistant professor of practical theology at Winebrenner Theological Seminary. He earned a doctor of ministry degree from Western Theological Seminary, alongside master’s degrees from Pittsburgh Theological Seminary and Baylor University’s George W. Truett Theological Seminary and a bachelor’s degree in African American studies from the University of Maryland. His latest book is In Those Days as Today: Preaching through the Book of Judges. Learn more at his website.


