Baptist News Global

Header Right

Sections

Main navigation

  • News
  • Opinion
    • Opinion Writers
    • Letters to the Editor
  • Curated
  • Projects
    • Faith & Justice
      • Charlotte: QC Family Tree with Greg and Helms Jarrell
  • More
    • Contact
    • About
    • Donate
    • Advertising
    • Ministry Jobs and More
    • Transitions
We are reader supported Donate
Search Search this site

What I have learned: The LGBT Issue, conclusion

OpinionDavid Gushee  |  October 28, 2014

Ten lessons learned in writing this series on LGBT issues.

My series on LGBT issues and the Church is now over. A version of these essays, together with prefatory material and introductory comments by Brian McLaren, Phyllis Tickle and Matthew Vines, is now out from Read the Spirit books under the title Changing Our Mind. I am deeply grateful to the staff of Baptist News Global for their cooperation in allowing these essays to be published in book form, and so quickly.

I undertook these reflections as a good-faith effort, in response to the suffering of LGBT Christians and my own calling as a Christian ethicist, to end “avoidism” on this issue by myself and in my religious world. For years, everyone has been waiting for someone else to take on the challenge. (“You first. No, after you.”) Finally, I took the plunge.

I have heard from scores of people around the nation and the world who have thanked me for making this attempt. Most touching have been the many messages from LGBT Christians, their friends, their parents and their ministers, thanking me for standing with them and their loved ones, and for providing ways into this issue that they find helpful.

I have also heard, of course, from a handful of Christians who have most definitely not thanked me. So now it’s your turn. I am confident that Baptist News Global will be happy to give you a chance to articulate an alternative perspective.

In this brief concluding column, I want to reflect on what I have learned in writing this series. Then I will take two weeks off for travel and speaking, and resume my column every other Monday, talking about whatever comes to mind. (Next column: an analysis of Gone Girl, both the book and the movie.) And soon I will be too busy making a fuss over our first grandchild to want to talk about anything other than that.

Here goes. Preparing this series, I have learned that:

1) Even though much progress can be made toward humane treatment of LGBT people without doing any new biblical work (see columns 1-7), addressing the most widely cited biblical texts on the traditionalist side still matters. Conversation about the LGBT issue is stymied by those who dismiss the significance of these texts as well as those who think there is nothing new to learn about them.

2) You really have to do your homework to work through those texts. This involves Hebrew and Greek work, consulting a range of biblical commentaries, reading in the most important works focusing on sexuality in the ancient world, and doing your own prayerful reflection. It’s a big job. There’s always more to do.

3) I think the best scholarly work on the background issues and interpretation of what the Bible says on sexuality is the five-part series by William Loader, an emeritus New Testament professor in Perth, Australia. If you must start with one book, go with his New Testament on Sexuality, which begins by summarizing key findings of his own previous works. The best single recent book both on the biblical material and the hermeneutical issues facing the church today is James Brownson’s Bible, Gender, Sexuality. The best memoir coming out of the conservative evangelical subculture is Justin Lee’s book, Torn.

4) Dealing seriously with the LGBT issue requires (a) biblical work as specified above, and (b) willingness to make the move from exegesis to hermeneutics, understood as interpretation of the biblical text in service to the Church today, then (c) Christian ethical consideration of this scriptural work, other major biblical texts and themes, and relevant extra-biblical sources of insight for thinking about this issue, which includes (d) attentiveness to the real struggling, suffering human beings whose lives and well-being are at stake in these moral deliberations. And then, of course (e), all moral discernment requires the mysterious and unverifiable guidance of the Holy Spirit.

5) Some are unwilling to acknowledge seriously steps (b) through (e). If they have worked out their exegesis on the six big passages, they have their answer to what the Church should do today. They do not attend seriously to suffering human beings. They do not acknowledge a pastoral task other than to report exegetical results. Often they scorn those who attempt to integrate real human suffering, and pastoral concern, into their response to the LGBT issue. They call it emotionalizing the issue. I think paying attention to neighbors bleeding by the side of the road is exactly what the love Jesus commanded looks like (Lk. 10:25-37).

Further, I have learned that:

6) Most Baptist News Global readers have demonstrated a laudable readiness to participate in the kind of conversation I have been attempting, however inadequately, to inspire in these columns. I am hopeful that more and more churches will move ahead with this discussion, properly resourced. Clearly there is no unanimity among readers or churches, but a community able to deal respectfully and lovingly with lack of unanimity is not a bad place to start.

7) Other readers, sadly, have not demonstrated such readiness. Some have reacted with outrage. Clearly this particular issue evokes emotions far exceeding that of other issues in our context at this moment.

8) There is a tragic dimension to this issue. It is tragic when Christians doing what they are trained to do — study Scripture faithfully, in service to Christ, trying to discern God’s will — badly hurt the very people they are trying to assist. It will be very good when this tragedy is brought to an end.

9) Our children are watching us old-timers wrestle with this issue. If we can’t figure it out, and in a way that doesn’t hurt their friends, they will just conclude that Christianity is of little relevance to their lives. After all, there is an easy way to resolve “the LGBT issue” — leave those churches (and families, and schools, and friends) where it is an issue, and go somewhere where it is not an issue. For some, especially millennials (as is well-documented), that has meant leaving God, Church, family, school and Bible altogether. That’s quite a price to pay.

10) It hurts to write about this subject. It offends people. It costs you sleep. It costs you friends. It gains you enemies. I keep thinking of the word “solidarity,” which in social ethics usually means leaving one’s own privileged position to identify with, enter into community with, and work alongside those fighting for dignity and for acceptance. An almost inevitable consequence of solidarity is that one gains the unpleasant but instructive experience of sharing in the indignities and rejections of the oppressed group.

The once-very-privileged Dietrich Bonhoeffer wrote from a Nazi prison to his once-very-privileged friends, saying:

“There remains an experience of incomparable value. We have for once learnt to see the great events of world history from below, from the perspective of the outcast, the suspects, the maltreated, the powerless, the oppressed, the reviled — in short, from the perspective of those who suffer.”


OPINION: Views expressed in Baptist News Global columns and commentaries are solely those of the authors.
Tags:CultureDavid GusheefaithPolitics
David Gushee
More by
David Gushee
  • Embracing the power of story

    Our first Storytelling Project — under the topic “Faith & Justice” — is a series on QC Family Tree, an intentional Christian community led by Greg and Helms Jarrell forming relationships and seeking justice alongside residents of the Enderly Park neighborhood of Charlotte, N.C. In “Faith & Justice,” we tell the stories of the people and organizations that are helping to bend the “arc of moral justice” toward justice and transforming communities.



    With little opportunity for youth and children — or almost anyone else — Christian community builds chances from the ground up

    For this intentional Christian community, seeking the world’s healing means battling gentrification close at home

    Video: How is QC Family Tree on the path toward justice?

    Photo Gallery: QC Family Tree in photos
  • Featured

    • Trump insult making life difficult for overseas missionaries

      News

    • Are white evangelicals sacrificing the future in search of the past?

      Curated

    • Lawsuit describes war on science at EPA

      News

    • For Christians, the green revolution is stalling — and politics may be why

      Curated

    Get BNG headlines in your inbox

    Read Next:

    In the present moment: afraid to speak, afraid to be silent

    OpinionRuss Dean

    More Articles

    • All
    • News
    • Opinion
    • Curated
    • Of all topics, why did John Piper choose to focus on the propriety of women teaching men?

      OpinionKate Hanch

    • Franklin Graham asserts that Trump could be toppled in a coup

      NewsBob Allen

    • Lucky the Jews didn’t understand what Mike Pence was really saying

      CuratedAmit Gvaryahu / Haaretz

    • Book explores why millions of Americans believe God made Trump president

      CuratedPolitico

    • Seeking Restoration

      Paid Promoted Content

    • Plans underway for the Alliance of Baptists’ 2018 Annual Gathering

      Paid Promoted Content

    • Baptists protest deportation of church member outside ICE office where he was detained

      NewsBob Allen

    • How can these things be? Making sense of evangelical politics

      CuratedDavid Wood / Bearings Online

    • For Christians, the green revolution is stalling — and politics may be why

      CuratedReligion News Service

    • Lawsuit describes war on science at EPA

      NewsBob Allen

    • Are white evangelicals sacrificing the future in search of the past?

      CuratedFiveThirtyEight

    • Remembering a staff colleague prompts questions about healthy church staffs

      OpinionBill Wilson

    • Florida lawmakers consider requiring schools to post ‘In God we trust’

      CuratedTampa Bay Times

    • Explore congregational wellbeing at ChurchWorks 2018

      Paid Promoted Content

    • Trump insult making life difficult for overseas missionaries

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Translating the N. T. Wright and David Bentley Hart Tussle

      CuratedChristianity Today

    • In the present moment: afraid to speak, afraid to be silent

      OpinionRuss Dean

    • Transitions for the week of 01.26.18

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • Pressler seeks gag order in lawsuit; SBC added as defendant

      NewsBob Allen

    • The apple does not fall far from the tree: Women’s rights, my mother and me

      OpinionNora Lozano

    • De tal palo, tal astilla: los derechos de la mujer, mi mamá y yo

      OpinionNora O. Lozano

    • It started as a joke: Only women could fix the ‘mess in the Middle East’

      CuratedHaaretz

    • Baptist upbringing inspires sociologist’s study of SBC controversy, American faith

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Pence: U.S. embassy to move to Jerusalem in 2019

      CuratedReligion News Service

    • Franklin Graham praises Trump as staunch defender of Christianity

      CuratedHuffington Post

    • Franklin Graham asserts that Trump could be toppled in a coup

      NewsBob Allen

    • Baptists protest deportation of church member outside ICE office where he was detained

      NewsBob Allen

    • Lawsuit describes war on science at EPA

      NewsBob Allen

    • Trump insult making life difficult for overseas missionaries

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Transitions for the week of 01.26.18

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • Pressler seeks gag order in lawsuit; SBC added as defendant

      NewsBob Allen

    • Baptist upbringing inspires sociologist’s study of SBC controversy, American faith

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • BWA head protests Bolivia’s religion law

      NewsBob Allen

    • Supreme Court to hear challenge to so-called Muslim ban

      NewsBob Allen

    • Judge says employment interference lawsuit against NAMB can proceed

      NewsBob Allen

    • Do-it-your-self faith on the rise thanks to the web, study finds

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • White House considering rollback of payday lending rule

      NewsBob Allen

    • Criticized for recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, White House cuts funding for Palestinian refugees

      NewsBob Allen

    • Transitions for the week of 01.19.18

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • These pastors see rural America — and its churches — as a growing mission field

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Evangelical supporter sees nothing racist about Trump immigration stance

      NewsBob Allen

    • White House says no one should have to choose between faith and law

      NewsBob Allen

    • Son of Francis Schaeffer calls out Trump’s evangelical enablers on Twitter

      NewsBob Allen

    • Megachurches must ‘come out of the closet’ on LGBTQ issues, say observers

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Baptist church fighting deportation of member with dire health concerns

      NewsBob Allen

    • Transitions for the week of 01.12.18

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • #MeToo spotlight turns on Southern Baptist megachurch

      NewsBob Allen

    • American pastor in Canada doesn’t miss culture wars, church growth pressures

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Immigrant advocates unhappy with White House decision to end temporary residency for Salvadorans

      NewsBob Allen

    • Mississippi ‘religious liberty’ bill allowed to stand

      NewsBob Allen

    • Of all topics, why did John Piper choose to focus on the propriety of women teaching men?

      OpinionKate Hanch

    • Remembering a staff colleague prompts questions about healthy church staffs

      OpinionBill Wilson

    • In the present moment: afraid to speak, afraid to be silent

      OpinionRuss Dean

    • The apple does not fall far from the tree: Women’s rights, my mother and me

      OpinionNora Lozano

    • De tal palo, tal astilla: los derechos de la mujer, mi mamá y yo

      OpinionNora O. Lozano

    • Marching toward the future for gender equality

      OpinionMolly T. Marshall

    • The day life changed for a legal immigrant — and his church

      OpinionLauren Efird

    • Breaking out: crossing the lines of old denominational structures

      OpinionJohn Chandler

    • Looking into the heart of racism and responding with … love

      OpinionCorey Fields

    • My father, the born-again socialist

      OpinionAlan Bean

    • Out of Africa: White supremacy and the Church’s silence

      OpinionBill Leonard

    • Looking for clues to thriving faith communities in a post-Christendom church

      OpinionJohn Chandler

    • If ‘The Post’ was a church, I would join

      OpinionBrett Younger

    • God lives in a really big house

      OpinionChuck Queen

    • Mental fitness and humility: You can’t have one without the other

      OpinionMolly T. Marshall

    • Dear Church, don’t give up on justice yet

      OpinionLaura Rector

    • How churches can combat the opioid crisis in 2018

      OpinionJonathan Davis

    • Making God smile through music

      OpinionDoyle Sager

    • For 2018: A fervent and frightened prayer

      OpinionBill Leonard

    • Goodbye, 2017. Won’t miss you much.

      OpinionAmy Butler

    • Lessons learned at a kitchen sink

      OpinionGreg Jarrell

    • American Evolution: Teddy Roosevelt and our national experiment

      OpinionDavid Jordan

    • Quietly pondering anew, what the Almighty can do

      OpinionMolly T. Marshall

    • Truth is stranger than fiction

      OpinionRuss Dean

    • Advent 2017: Bad news to the poor

      OpinionBill Leonard

    • Lucky the Jews didn’t understand what Mike Pence was really saying

      CuratedAmit Gvaryahu / Haaretz

    • Book explores why millions of Americans believe God made Trump president

      CuratedPolitico

    • How can these things be? Making sense of evangelical politics

      CuratedDavid Wood / Bearings Online

    • For Christians, the green revolution is stalling — and politics may be why

      CuratedReligion News Service

    • Are white evangelicals sacrificing the future in search of the past?

      CuratedFiveThirtyEight

    • Florida lawmakers consider requiring schools to post ‘In God we trust’

      CuratedTampa Bay Times

    • Translating the N. T. Wright and David Bentley Hart Tussle

      CuratedChristianity Today

    • It started as a joke: Only women could fix the ‘mess in the Middle East’

      CuratedHaaretz

    • Pence: U.S. embassy to move to Jerusalem in 2019

      CuratedReligion News Service

    • Franklin Graham praises Trump as staunch defender of Christianity

      CuratedHuffington Post

    • Protestant, Muslim, Atheist, Jew: 4 leftist perspectives a year into Trump’s presidency

      CuratedReligion News Service

    • First year of Trump-Pence brings bountiful blessings, religious conservatives say

      CuratedUSA Today

    • Author of books on presidents’ faith says Trump misunderstands evangelicals

      CuratedReligion News Service

    • Pope shocks Chile by accusing sex abuse victims of slander

      CuratedAssociated Press

    • How podcasting hurts preaching

      CuratedChristianity Today

    • Yes, your ancestors probably did come here legally — because ‘illegal’ immigration is less than a century old

      CuratedKevin Jennings / Los Angeles Times

    • 82 rabbis, activists arrested On Capitol Hill over DACA protest

      CuratedHuffington Post

    • Christianity is not getting greener

      CuratedScientific American

    • Salvadorans at risk of losing immigration status find support in churches

      CuratedReligion News Service

    • Sexual harassment in the church: Apology ‘has never been enough’

      CuratedNPR

    • Pope begs forgiveness for ‘irreparable harm’ from sex abuse

      CuratedAssociated Press

    • China church demolition sparks fears of campaign against Christians

      CuratedThe Guardian

    • Andy Savage says he will take leave of absence from ministry

      CuratedCommercial Appeal

    • American exceptionalism and America First

      CuratedReligion & Politics

    • 5 things I wish my pastors had told me

      CuratedMatthew Distefano / Patheos

    Conversations that Matter.

    © 2018 Baptist News Global. All rights reserved.

    Want to share a story? We hope you will! Read our republishing, terms of use and privacy policies here.

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Google+
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS