I am a child of North Carolina. A Tar Heel born, a Tar Heel bred.
This meant summers spent running between the broad, sticky leaves of my grandfather’s tobacco fields. It meant family car rides toward the coast to visit Carolina, Atlantic or Wrightsville Beach. In the fall, our minivan headed in the opposite direction. We’d steadily climb rolling hills, noting the changing of leaves from school bus yellow to the dark birthmark hue of reds and purples. My sister and I killed time trying to kill one another by playing “punch buggy” until we saw the slab of rock made famous by The Andy Griffith Show. Pilot Mountain still produces awe in me when she first comes into view.
Growing up here afforded me the luxury of eating some of the best barbecue in the world. I cut my teeth on Lexington-style, and so I love it without apology. I’ll defend it to those on the eastern side of the state who prefer their vinegar-soaked whole hog to my bright, sweet-and-sour tomato-dipped pork shoulder.
From this, I learned we could argue over just about anything.
You had to pick a side when it came to pronouncing things. What kind of pie you got there? Puh-KAHN or a PEE-can? You from the mountains of app-uh-LATCH-uh, or app-uh-LAY-shun?
Decisions had to be made on such serious matters — none more important than college basketball allegiance.
There was little choice in my house. My father was a University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill fan. He bequeathed to me an unwavering, undying and at times unhealthy passion for Carolina basketball.
Michael Jordan had come and gone by the time I was old enough to give a damn. My conversion came in 1993 when UNC defeated Michigan’s Fab Five. I expected a repeat the following year. Many starters returned along with a couple of phenomenal freshmen. Ranked No. 1 at the start and end of the regular season, Carolina was expected to win.
And then the unthinkable: A second-round elimination by Boston College.
I was 13 years old, and this broke my heart the way a first love does a high school relationship. UNC was supposed to win. They had the best coach and players. What just happened?
Over the next few days, I allowed myself to come to the realization that Carolina had lost. I just didn’t want to believe the other team had beaten us.
Midterms shock
Maybe that’s how some people feel after these midterms.
Here in the Old North State, early voting numbers were record-breaking. Democrats won a U.S. Senate race. The first time since 2008. They’ve flipped six of the state’s 10 Republican-held congressional seats. One more seems likely. A blue wave, pushed by the winds of change, crashed over the Outer Banks and didn’t crest until it hit the Tennessee state line.
“I guess you can redraw the lines all you want, but you can’t tell people how to vote.”
Political analysis weighed in, saying North Carolina Republicans’ gerrymandering plans came back and bit them. I guess you can redraw the lines all you want, but you can’t tell people how to vote.
With little suprise, the Doomsday commentary from evangelicals and the Religious Right started almost immediately.
Franklin Graham chimed in on Twitter, “The midterms are now over, leaving some very concerned — while others are elated. We see our country inching closer toward socialism, which is historically an enemy of God and his word.”
Allen Jackson, senior pastor of World Outreach Church in Murfreesboro, Tenn., said, “We just elected a number of people, and have given them authority in our nation, who share values that are reflected in either the Islamic or the socialist, communist values in those nations that very aggressively diminish Christianity.”
Worship Leader Sean Feucht posted on X, “THE CHURCH STAYED HOME!”
These comments came after hearing that LaKesha Womack, an ordained African Methodist Episcopal Zion minister, won her district here in North Carolina. After Frederick Douglass Haynes III, a long-time social justice advocate and pastor of Friendship-West Baptist Church in Dallas, won. And after Presbyterian USA minister Lindsay James claimed a seat in Iowa. After Presbyterian seminarian James Talarico in Texas and United Methodist pastor Adam Hamilton of Kansas joined them.
Their support on issues ranging from universal health care and child care, tuition-free education and defunding never-ending wars brought criticism and cries that the United States had lost its way. But it also brought something else — shocking disbelief.
Like me staring at a basketball score in 1994, Graham, Jackson and Feucht are left wondering: What just happened?
Coming to terms with losing is hard. Especially when you’ve convinced yourself you were always supposed to win. In a ballgame, you can point fingers at the refs for a bad call or come down on the coach. Hell, I’ve spent days trying to figure out why a player took a hard shot when they had a wide-open pass that all but guaranteed an easy bucket. I’ve cussed and mourned over it all. But none of that changed anything. Sooner or later, I had to look up at the scoreboard and admit what happened.
This is what we all should do. That, or you decide to tell the story a little differently.
Redefining loss
North Carolina knows something about loss. The entire South does too. We lost a war. Well, the Confederacy lost a war, but you wouldn’t know that by the way some people around here still carry on about it.
A new story started unfolding across the South when the war ended, and Reconstruction began. The Confederacy became a noble cause. Its soldiers were the heroes. Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee were its prophets. Slavery got tucked quietly away, and the whole issue became about the fight for states’ rights. The war wasn’t civil. The war came about because of “Northern aggression.” Southern pulpits jumped on the narrative that the South hadn’t really lost the war; God was just purifying us. “He” was still very much on our side.
“Many in the South accepted this new religion because it allowed them to make a losing cause look like a righteous one.”
A Virginian journalist is credited with giving this story a name. In 1866, Edward A. Pollard called it “The Lost Cause.” And many in the South accepted this new religion because it allowed them to make a losing cause look like a righteous one. I suppose a people who felt like their country and way of life were being taken away from them needed something to make sense of it all.
Roughly 100 years later, the South did something similar. In the 1960s and ’70s, the United States saw a revolution of rapid social change. The Civil Rights Movement gained momentum. The feminist movement was underway. Family structures began to change. Abortion became legal. Christian leaders like Jerry Falwell used their pulpits to reach the masses. Convincing those across the country, particularly those in the Bible Belt, that the values that once made us a “city on a hill” were being pushed aside by people who didn’t share their faith or understand their history.
To say Falwell and the Moral Majority were a success is an understatement. They galvanized a people and organized conservative Christians around the belief that America was in moral decline and needed to be reclaimed. The outcome was atomic: Politics and religion openly slipped into bed with each other. Both saw the benefits. Both saw the power. They’ve never wanted to let it go.
Cue the MAGA movement. Cue January 6. Cue evangelicals and the Religious Right struggling to accept that the country might want something different than what they’ve been selling. Cue the continuation of the Lost Cause, finding another way not to accept the scoreboard.
“We need to stop associating winning elections with evidence of God’s favor.”
Now, two weeks removed from the midterms, I find myself wondering whose Christianity counts in this country. That of Franklin Graham, Allen Jackson and Sean Feucht? Or that of Talarico, Hamilton, Womack? I dunno. But I feel those who profess a faith have a reckoning coming around the notion that God automatically endorses a political position or a particular candidate.
We need to stop associating winning elections with evidence of God’s favor. We also need to stop seeing losing elections as evidence that the country has abandoned God or God has abandoned the country. God doesn’t lose elections. Politicians do. Political parties do. And recently, shamefully, it seems some churches do, too.
For followers of the lowly Galilean, we must remember the unsteepled church Jesus started existed long before the United States. It survived empires, persecution and political upheaval. The church then and now has never needed government to fulfill her calling.
Let that message fly from brave pulpits this and every Sunday.
And for God’s sake, let the church, God’s people, deal with the scoreboard.
Justin Cox received his theological education from Campbell University and Wake Forest University School of Divinity and McAfee School of Theology, where he received his doctor of ministry. He is an ordained minister holding standing in the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship and American Baptist Churches USA. When not spending time with his spouse and daughters, he can be found writing and baking late into the night. His thoughts and reflections are his own.


