When a woke young ACLU fundraiser tries to get money from a rich old liberal in the Off Broadway play The Ask, the ministers in the audience take notes for their next stewardship sermon.
Marilu Henner, who played Elaine on the 1970s TV show Taxi, is Greta, a wealthy widow and longtime donor who stopped giving. Greta has a mockup photograph of a brontosaurus on her wall, “I call it my self-portrait. A dinosaur, surrounded by real-life.”
Shannon Purser, whose character Barb was murdered in the third episode of Stranger Things in 2016 but was nominated for an Emmy anyway, is Tanner, a nonbinary ACLU gift planning office representative sent to find out why Greta stopped giving and ask for another gift. Nonprofit groups often employ young people to get money from old people.
Greta feels like her money has been wasted on things that don’t matter. She doesn’t like the language they use in fundraising emails, particularly the phrase “pregnant people.” She wants things to be the way they used to be.
Tanner would like to dismiss the old woman as out of touch, but it’s a long trip from Bushwick to the Upper West Side, and they want the money. Young idealists need someone to pay the bills. Their intergenerational confrontation goes on for an hour and 15 minutes. The older woman has been waiting a long time to be heard.
Their difficult conversation is common in charitable giving. It is hard to ask people for their money. Nonprofit solicitation is complicated.
“Their difficult conversation is common in charitable giving.”
Tanner supplies a boatload of information about various methods by which Greta could donate while improving her tax position. Greta is completely uninterested in this, but Tanner is building up to make the specific “ask” of the title. Spoiler alert: It is a half million dollars.
Greta is wounded by the way the world has changed. She feels the organization’s values have been lost. Her distress and principles are genuine, but so is her inability to understand where Tanner is coming from. Tanner’s afraid to disagree but also does not want to make promises they can’t keep just to get the money.
They believe in many of the same things, but they want everything their own way. They argue about how institutions grapple with generational change and evolve with the times. Should the people giving the money decide the mission? The conversation turns into a contentious debate. Tanner keeps explaining that their organization is filled with people who disagree about their mission.
Finally, an exasperated Tanner says, “I want you to give a gift that will make you happy.”
That is when the audience laughs.
No one in the theater thought that was going to happen. We were right. Greta makes the donation but it doesn’t make anyone happy. She wants to force the group to go back to its old ways. Tanner swallows hard and compromises their values to get the money. The gift makes them unhappy.
That happens. We usually like sharing what we have, even as we wish we enjoyed it more. Sometimes we give and don’t feel much. We know giving is the right thing to do, but it can be routine. We suspect we are not actually generous and may never be. What we are missing is the sense that our giving comes from a place of hope, imagination and authenticity.
“What we are missing is the sense that our giving comes from a place of hope, imagination and authenticity.”
Giving is not trendy. Greed is more popular. Apathy is always in style. Giving what feels safe is normal.
Giving what is expected is not what we should expect, because it is not as much fun as giving generously. We become generous by putting ourselves in the path of all kinds of beauty, people and pain, developing reflexes of awe, delight and compassion.
When we hear the old school word “stewardship,” we may think of church campaigns aimed at cajoling, harping and bugging people to fill out a pledge card, but stewardship is about who we are going to be.
The Spirit shapes us into the image of Jesus, not for our sake, but for the sake of others. We become giving people to help the love of God break through a little bit more tomorrow that it did today.
In a sermon at Riverside Church on the Upper West Side, Ernest Campbell preached: “To be young is to study in schools that you did not build. To be mature is to build schools in which you will not study. To be young is to swim in pools that you did not dig. To be mature is to dig pools in which you will not swim. To be young is to sit under trees you did not plant. To be mature is to plant trees under which you will not sit. To be young is to dance to music you did not write. To be mature is to write music to which you will not dance. To be young is to benefit from a church you did not make. To be mature is to make a church from which you might not benefit.”
If we listen carefully, we might hear God say, “I want you to give a gift that will make you happy.”
Brett Younger serves as senior minister at Plymouth Church in Brooklyn, N.Y.


