Whether they wanted him to or not, Franklin Graham has weighed in on the schism at Highland Park Methodist Church in Dallas.
Meanwhile, a Dallas judge issued a temporary ruling Nov. 18 in a dispute over church names.
The congregation formerly known as Highland Park United Methodist Church has made national headlines with its recent vote to disaffiliate from The United Methodist Church. Church leaders have been careful to say the move was driven by the conference bishop not accepting their unilateral change in governing documents in defiance of United Methodist governance. They have not made any public statements about the UMC becoming too liberal, too accepting of LGBTQ Christians or about any kind of theological disagreement.
But Graham, who lives in North Carolina and has no affiliation with the church, made his views known Monday on X. He praised former U.S. President George W. Bush and his wife, Laura, who are members of the church, for speaking out in favor of disaffiliation.
“Thank you, Highland Park Methodist Church and President Bush, for doing the right thing and standing with the word of God,” Graham said.
The evangelist declared the disaffiliation was “because of issues including the ordination of LGBTQ clergy and the performance of same-sex marriages. They chose to stand up against the unbiblical progressive movement that has hijacked the United Methodist denomination.”
Highland Park Church leaders have said no such thing publicly.
In fact, on Monday, church leaders issued a statement to the Dallas Morning News: “HPMC’s decision to separate from the UMC is not about LGBTQ issues; it is about governance and preserving our historic autonomy.”
Nevertheless, Graham persisted in his view when contacted by the Morning News for clarification: “The denomination’s stance is leading people away from the truth set forth in his word, the Bible, and away from him. I believe that’s why thousands of Bible-believing, Bible-teaching churches have had to leave the denomination. I’m proud of the congregation at Highland Park Methodist Church for making that same decision last month and standing with the unchanging truth of God’s word.”
“HPMC’s decision to separate from the UMC is not about LGBTQ issues; it is about governance and preserving our historic autonomy.”
While the Highland Park Church does not allow same-sex weddings in its building, it does allow its clergy to officiate them anywhere else. By most accounts, the congregation is divided on the question.
Meanwhile, a Dallas County judge issued a temporary ruling Nov. 18 barring Horizon Texas Conference of the UMC from using the name “Highland Park United Methodist Church.” Bishop Ruben Saenz has created a church in exile — mainly comprised of people who vote no on disaffiliation and who want to remain in a UMC church. That congregation has billed itself with the 110-year-old congregation’s former name, insisting they are the true continuation of that legacy.
Caroline Nowlin, chair of the HPMC Church Council, and Mark Freeman, chair of the Pastoral Relations Committee, issued a joint statement in response.
“This decision affirms what we have sought to protect from the beginning: The history, legal identity and goodwill of Highland Park Methodist Church,” they said. “We wish our neighbors well and respect their right to worship and build a faith community under a name that does not infringe on our historic trademarks or create confusion within our community.”
They reiterated that everything the original church has done was about protecting “a legacy of faith.”
The order from Judge Bridgett Whitmore bars Horizon Texas Conference and related parties from using the names “Highland Park United Methodist Church,” “Highland Park United Methodists,” “Highland Park UMC,” “HPUMC,” “HPUMC Oasis,” or “any other designation confusingly similar to the HP marks.”
The order expires on Dec. 2 at 4 p.m., which is the time of a scheduled hearing on the matter before the court.
Andy Lewis, who was named by the bishop as pastor of the church in exile, wrote to his congregation: “This news is disappointing, but I want you to hear from me that I remain undeterred in our mission to offer a United Methodist ministry and witness to the Highland Park community and beyond. There is an unmistakable flame of faith and commitment that is burning in our congregation, and this temporary setback will not snuff it out.”
Related:
Now Dallas Methodists are fighting over a name
Highland Park Methodist’s story is not a first | Analysis by Mark Wingfield
Today’s UMC has only 3 megachurches | Analysis by Mark Wingfield
In Dallas, Methodist bishop creates a church in exile
Highland Park Methodist and the death of denominationalism | Analysis by Mark Wingfield
3 reasons all churches should pay attention to HPUMC right now | Analysis by Mark Wingfield


