Baptist News Global
Sections
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • Curated
  • Storytelling
    • Faith & Justice >
      • Charleston: Metanoia with Bill Stanfield
      • Charlotte: QC Family Tree with Greg and Helms Jarrell
      • Little Rock: Judge Wendell Griffen
      • North Carolina: Conetoe
    • Welcoming the Stranger >
      • Lost Boys of Sudan: St. John’s Baptist Charlotte
      • Awakening to Immigrant Justice: Myers Park Baptist Church
      • Hospitality on the corner: Gaston Christian Center
    • Signature Ministries >
      • Jake Hall: Gospel Gothic, Music and Radio
    • Singing Our Faith >
      • Hymns for a Lifetime: Ken Wilson and Knollwood Baptist Church
      • Norfolk Street Choir
    • Resilient Rural America >
      • Alabama: Perry County
      • Texas: Hidalgo County
      • Arkansas Delta
      • Southeast Kentucky
  • More
    • Contact
    • About
    • Donate
    • Associated Baptist Press Foundation
    • Planned Giving
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Advertising
    • Ministry Jobs and More
    • Transitions
    • Subscribe
    • Submissions and Permissions
Donate Subscribe
Search Search this site

The Cross is not enough: Baptists, catholicity and the atonement

OpinionCurtis W. Freeman and Steven R. Harmon  |  July 7, 2017

Editor’s note: We recently published Steve Harmon’s and Curtis Freeman’s response to the Southern Baptist Convention’s affirmation of the theological concept of penal substitutionary atonement. That prompted a reply from two Southern Baptist writers, Lucas Stamps and Matthew Emerson. Harmon and Freeman are continuing the conversation with the following piece.

We want to express our appreciation to Lucas Stamps and Matthew Emerson in their call for Southern Baptists to reclaim the whole of the Christian faith and heritage. We regard them as fellow pilgrims on a journey, not of returning to an un-historicized ideal of biblical Christianity or even to our radically reformed Baptist roots, but toward participation in the life of the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic church, which encompasses more, not less, of our identity in Christ. As fellow travelers, we share much in common, especially in the desire to reclaim the catholicity that belongs to all Christians. As the Apostle Paul reminds us, all things are ours, and we are Christ’s, and Christ is God’s (1 Cor. 3:21-23). This is the catholicity we seek. Yet the nature of this unity is a matter of contestation. We offer a rejoinder to their response to our article on violence and the atonement, then, not as an act of debate or correction, but rather of clarification.

We want to be clear that we seek to embrace all biblical images of the drama of God’s reconciling work in Jesus Christ. We share the concern expressed in the Southern Baptist resolution that the language of Christ’s vicarious suffering is inescapable, and indeed essential to the gospel. Scripture attests to him as bearing “our infirmities and diseases,” being “wounded for our transgressions” and “crushed for our iniquities,” and having “laid on him the iniquity of us all” (Isaiah 53:4-6). Though prophetic texts like this one have a complex hermeneutical horizon, we nevertheless share the conviction with the earliest Christians and with Christians through the ages, who identified these descriptions as finding their fulfillment in Jesus of Nazareth (Act 8:35).

Part of our struggle is with the suggestion that this suffering is more, or rather different. That Christ’s death is penal. That the cross should be thought of primarily, if not exclusively, as canceling the guilt of past transgression. Our problem with this expression is that penal suffering is not redemptive suffering. As Baptist theologian W. T. Conner put it in his classic statement The Gospel of Redemption, “The cross of Christ as presented in the New Testament does more than cancel the guilt of past sin; it is the one and only source and dynamic of the Christian life.” We worry that in pushing back so hard against critics who refuse to accept the vicarious suffering of Jesus, the Southern Baptist statement narrows the scope of Christ’s redemptive work to this one image, and in so doing impoverishes the gospel.

To give a faithful account of the deliverance of God in Jesus Christ requires more than telling the story of the cross. Any theology that seeks to do justice to the whole of Scripture must understand Christ’s atoning work as transformational, encompassing his life, death, resurrection and glorification. It demands a presentation of the incarnate faithfulness of Jesus Christ who, as Athanasius of Alexandria succinctly said, “became what we are that we might become what he is.” The problem is that for much of evangelical theology, the Incarnation simply does no theological work. It only serves the purpose of getting Jesus to earth so he can die for our sins. Here we note that the Nicene Creed confesses that “for us humans and for our salvation [Christ] came down from the heavens and became incarnate from the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary.”

It is not surprising, then, that the Apostle Paul declares that “we were reconciled to God through the death of his Son,” and thus “having been reconciled, will we be saved by his life” (Rom. 5:10). It is this sense of being saved by Christ’s life, not simply by his death, that we turn to the non-violent servanthood embodied in the life of Jesus as a source of our transformation. By learning to follow him in this way of radical obedience we learn what it means to live into this salvation that he made possible — a way that includes learning to be reconciled with our enemies without resorting to violence.

We commend Matt Emerson’s critique of evangelical Christians who refuse to address the violent culture of systemic injustice that continues to result in the deaths of so many innocent African Americans. However, we contend that the root of the problem is not simply a “truncated canon,” but rather of a notion of violence that is inherent to the preaching of many evangelical Christians, indeed to many Southern Baptists. As we said in our earlier statement, the preaching of a penal substitutionary view, not merely its caricature, presents an account of the cross in which God is violent and the endorser of violence. We contend that this is a truncated account of the gospel. And we further contend that limiting the redemptive work of Christ to the cross, interpreted exclusively in penal terms, results in (as the SBC resolution explicitly states) “a warrior-savior,” which underwrites and endorses the very violence they wish to critique.

We agree with Stamps and Emerson that “substitution, recapitulation, and victory go hand-in-hand.” But we worry that rather than broadening the scope of God’s reconciling work, the SBC resolution narrows the focus, not just to one image, but to an even narrower “theory of atonement,” which explains, as the resolution states, “what evangelical Baptists have long since preached and believed.” We reject the notion of theorizing the atonement, and instead regard the so-called theories, summarized as “substitution, recapitulation, and victory” to be theological applications of root metaphors in Scripture pointing to the redemptive sacrifice of Christ. To put it simply, we do not believe that any theory sufficiently displays God’s reconciling work.

It is simply not the case that penal substitution is that faith which has been believed “everywhere, always, by all.” It has been and remains a divisive and disputed doctrine, not a catholic one. It is affirmed only by some Protestants, and until recently it was judiciously omitted from the Baptist Faith and Message statements. The early church in its ecumenical councils was wise not to include as the orthodox faith any particular interpretation of the manner in which the cross of Christ saves us. Rather than theorizing, we argue that the only way to give a faithful account of redemption is “to tell the old, old story of Jesus and his love.” We fear that subsuming the deliverance of God into the conception of “retributive justice,” as Emerson and Stamps suggest, further abstracts our experience of redemption from the Gospel narrative which does not explain how, but only tells by whom this mystery is wrought.

The grace that meets the world in Jesus Christ is a sheer gift that is radically discontinuous with what comes before. In Christ a new world has come. The old humanity of Adam’s race is fallen and imprisoned. It is fading away. The new humanity that comes through Christ is a reconciled and redeemed creation. In Christ the old has passed away, and the new has come into being (2 Cor. 5:17). The reconciling work of Christ thus frees all the sons and daughters of earth from the powers that would determine their lives and opens up the space in which it is possible to live as free people. That is good news.

Related story:

Satisfaction guaranteed: Southern Baptists refute efforts to soften the atonement

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)

OPINION: Views expressed in Baptist News Global columns and commentaries are solely those of the authors.
More by
Curtis W. Freeman and Steven R. Harmon
  • Get BNG headlines in your inbox

  • Featured

    • What did Pope Francis say, and what did he mean, in AP interview on homosexuality?

      Analysis

    • Biden administration urged to remove Cuba from list of state sponsors of terrorism

      News

    • Jesus and Buddha are talking with me about loving and blessing my enemies

      Opinion

    • Zimbabwean pastors flee ministry to join more lucrative care work in the UK

      News


    Curated

    • GOP Rep. Who Spoke At Pro-Hitler Event Goes After Ilhan Omar Because Of ‘Anti-Semitism’

      GOP Rep. Who Spoke At Pro-Hitler Event Goes After Ilhan Omar Because Of ‘Anti-Semitism’

    • Psychedelic churches in US pushing boundaries of religion

      Psychedelic churches in US pushing boundaries of religion

    • Prominent Jewish leaders add to drumbeat of criticism of Israel’s new government

      Prominent Jewish leaders add to drumbeat of criticism of Israel’s new government

    • At Tyre Nichols’ funeral, VP Harris and Sharpton among those praying and promising reform

      At Tyre Nichols’ funeral, VP Harris and Sharpton among those praying and promising reform

    Read Next:

    Nonreligious young adults say they are more open to religion than older adults, but campus ministers say that’s still a delicate opportunity

    AnalysisMallory Challis

    More Articles

    • All
    • News
    • Opinion
    • Curated
    • Title 42, congregations and the sojourner

      OpinionSean Powell

    • SBC Executive Committee member once again criticized for sexually crude social media posts

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • The truth about police brutality

      OpinionJames Ellis III

    • In Ukraine: ‘We cannot just preach like we did before the war’

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • TikTok trends and three questions you and your church should ask this year about rest

      AnalysisLaura Ellis

    • Two churches ‘under inquiry’ by SBC Credentials Committee for platforming Johnny Hunt

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Biblical orthodoxy 2023: Sign or get ‘churched’

      OpinionBill Leonard, Senior Columnist

    • Zimbabwean pastors flee ministry to join more lucrative care work in the UK

      NewsRay Mwareya

    • Jesus and Buddha are talking with me about loving and blessing my enemies

      OpinionH. Stephen Shoemaker

    • Biden administration urged to remove Cuba from list of state sponsors of terrorism

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Why most everything you think you know about global migration is probably wrong

      AnalysisMark Wingfield

    • What did Pope Francis say, and what did he mean, in AP interview on homosexuality?

      AnalysisMallory Challis

    • Transitions for the week of 2-3-23

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • Letter to the Editor: Kudos all around for Baptist News Global

      OpinionLetters to the Editor

    • Letter to the Editor: Jesus expects us to follow him; Trump expects us to follow him

      OpinionLetters to the Editor

    • Humor and hope mark the dark journey taken by a creative and brave photojournalist

      OpinionKathy Manis Findley

    • ‘Can you imagine looting the religious artifacts that help strengthen the Christian faith from the Vatican?’

      NewsAnthony Akaeze

    • One year of sobriety

      OpinionGlen Schmucker

    • Panelists discuss how the Hamline University controversy could have been handled better in a diverse culture

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Men’s ministry needs more than, eggs, bacon and football

      OpinionMaina Mwaura

    • Nonreligious young adults say they are more open to religion than older adults, but campus ministers say that’s still a delicate opportunity

      AnalysisMallory Challis

    • Pope Francis arrives in Africa on a two-nation tour seeking peace amid decades of conflict

      NewsAnthony Akaeze

    • The church must show the world a more excellent way of nonviolence

      OpinionRodney Kennedy

    • Museum of the Bible to host Wednesday morning event to pray for God’s judgment on America, and breakfast is not included

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • National Prayer Breakfast gets new sponsorship but still looks like government-sponsored religion, BJC leaders say

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • SBC Executive Committee member once again criticized for sexually crude social media posts

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • In Ukraine: ‘We cannot just preach like we did before the war’

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Two churches ‘under inquiry’ by SBC Credentials Committee for platforming Johnny Hunt

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Zimbabwean pastors flee ministry to join more lucrative care work in the UK

      NewsRay Mwareya

    • Biden administration urged to remove Cuba from list of state sponsors of terrorism

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Transitions for the week of 2-3-23

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • ‘Can you imagine looting the religious artifacts that help strengthen the Christian faith from the Vatican?’

      NewsAnthony Akaeze

    • Panelists discuss how the Hamline University controversy could have been handled better in a diverse culture

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Pope Francis arrives in Africa on a two-nation tour seeking peace amid decades of conflict

      NewsAnthony Akaeze

    • Museum of the Bible to host Wednesday morning event to pray for God’s judgment on America, and breakfast is not included

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • National Prayer Breakfast gets new sponsorship but still looks like government-sponsored religion, BJC leaders say

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Ministry jobs and more

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • Zimbabwe Theological Seminary names new principal

      NewsBNG staff

    • What happens when church and state merge? Look to Nazi Germany for answers

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Southwestern Seminary student arrested for alleged ‘felony sexual assault’

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Trial date set for Patterson and Southwestern versus Jane Roe

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Faith groups must fight online hate, Interfaith Alliance urges

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Colorado cake maker back in court, this time for refusing service to a transgender woman

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • For every critic of Jesus and John Wayne there are many more positive responses Du Mez says

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Bob Banks, longtime SBC missions leader, dies at 91

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Members of Florida church required to sign ‘biblical sexuality’ statement or be removed from membership

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • Eight months later, there’s renewed interest in Adam Hamilton’s video on why he’ll remain a United Methodist

      NewsMark Wingfield

    • 165 religious leaders plead with White House to abandon immigrant travel ban

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Ministry jobs and more

      NewsBarbara Francis

    • Knowing a church’s history on slavery can be a nudge toward redemption, historians say

      NewsJeff Brumley

    • Title 42, congregations and the sojourner

      OpinionSean Powell

    • The truth about police brutality

      OpinionJames Ellis III

    • Biblical orthodoxy 2023: Sign or get ‘churched’

      OpinionBill Leonard, Senior Columnist

    • Jesus and Buddha are talking with me about loving and blessing my enemies

      OpinionH. Stephen Shoemaker

    • Letter to the Editor: Kudos all around for Baptist News Global

      OpinionLetters to the Editor

    • Letter to the Editor: Jesus expects us to follow him; Trump expects us to follow him

      OpinionLetters to the Editor

    • Humor and hope mark the dark journey taken by a creative and brave photojournalist

      OpinionKathy Manis Findley

    • One year of sobriety

      OpinionGlen Schmucker

    • Men’s ministry needs more than, eggs, bacon and football

      OpinionMaina Mwaura

    • The church must show the world a more excellent way of nonviolence

      OpinionRodney Kennedy

    • Church historian Richard Hughes reflects on a lifetime of ‘Troublesome Questions’

      OpinionTed Parks

    • What churches could learn from the Pub Choir phenomenon

      OpinionMike Frost

    • Living into lament: A white response to the killing of Tyre Nichols by police

      OpinionRobert P. Jones

    • Of church cemeteries, pulpit committees, crafts and sweet potato casserole

      OpinionChris Ayers

    • Of Margie, mountains and ‘El Shaddai’

      OpinionBert Montgomery

    • What I learned from meeting Martin Luther King in Louisville and Josie in Hopkinsville

      OpinionBill Thurman

    • On the baptism of our firstborn

      OpinionEmily Hull McGee

    • Has virtual worship actually harmed Christianity?

      OpinionSara Robb-Scott

    • ‘What can we forgive?’: An interview with Matthew Ichihashi Potts on Forgiveness

      OpinionGreg Garrett, Senior Columnist

    • My father’s faith

      OpinionBrett Younger

    • The apology that never came at Bubba-Doo’s

      OpinionCharles Qualls

    • Trump and his allegedly disloyal white evangelical supporters

      OpinionRobert P. Jones

    • Doom-scrolling, sourdough starter and three kinds of kin

      OpinionJustin Cox

    • Putin needs to be taken down

      OpinionMark Wingfield

    • How my eyes were opened to America’s broken immigration system

      OpinionChristian Vaughn

    • GOP Rep. Who Spoke At Pro-Hitler Event Goes After Ilhan Omar Because Of ‘Anti-Semitism’

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Psychedelic churches in US pushing boundaries of religion

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Prominent Jewish leaders add to drumbeat of criticism of Israel’s new government

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • At Tyre Nichols’ funeral, VP Harris and Sharpton among those praying and promising reform

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Marvin Olasky Still Wants to Make Journalism Biblically Objective

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Progressive National Baptists to deploy $1 million grant to boost ‘compelling preaching’

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Church of England sheds light on ‘shameful’ slave trade ties

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Chinese Christians remain in Thailand fearing deportation

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Black police officers aren’t colorblind – they’re infected by the same anti-Black bias as American society and police in general

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Ohio is investigating a Nazi homeschooling network that teaches children to love Hitler

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Omar says some Republicans don’t want a Muslim in Congress: ‘These people are OK with Islamophobia’

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Tyre Nichols police beating video prompts faith leaders to react with grief, goals

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • How Egyptian police hunt LGBT people on dating apps

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • N. Carolina church says it lost nearly $800K in email scam

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • On A Mission To Fill Empty Pulpits: A Couple Addressing The Preacher Shortage

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Second gentleman Emhoff visits Auschwitz, part of a push against antisemitism

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • A Buddhist disaster relief organization offers key support after Monterey Park shooting

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • It shouldn’t seem so surprising when the pope says being gay ‘isn’t a crime’ – a Catholic theologian explains

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • USCCB official: The church must admit its role in destroying Native American culture

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • House bill would limit government authority over religious events

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • ‘He Gets Us’ organizers hope to spend $1 billion to promote Jesus. Will anyone care?

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • The Rise of Spirit Warriors on the Christian Right

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • Twitter reinstated white nationalist Nick Fuentes. He lasted 24 hours.

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • In Rare Rebuke, Elaine Chao Calls Out Trump’s Anti-Asian Attacks

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    • How Southern California helped birth white Christian nationalism

      Curated

      Exclude from home pageBNG staff

    Conversations that Matter.

    © 2023 Baptist News Global. All rights reserved.

    Want to share a story? We hope you will! Read our republishing, terms of use and privacy policies here.

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS