Many years ago, the famous poet Rainer Maria Rilke wrote a small book, Letters to a Young Poet. One of Rilke’s most famous passages in the book was about living the questions: “Have patience with everything unresolved in your heart. … Live the questions now. Perhaps then, someday far in the future, you will gradually, without even noticing it, live your way into the answer.”
If I were writing Letters to a Young Minister, the first concept I would convey is mystery — the mystery of God that surrounds us and holds us and sometimes chastens us when we pretend to know more than we can know. Living the questions leaves room for mystery.
Most of us are “picked green” as we enter ministry. We have to assume a knowledge and spiritual authority we cannot possibly possess at a young age, or any age. It can stunt our spiritual growth; it can puff us up.
People do not come to church as much for answers as for wisdom. They come seeking mystery and longing for a mystery whose face is the face of love.
Eduard Schweizer, the Swiss New Testament scholar, was asked when he came to America what he thought about our preaching. He answered that it was “too perfect,” that preachers preach as if they have the final word to say about a particular text, about God. A sermon, he said, should have the posture of one seeking to convey a truth just beyond its grasp, a leaning into mystery.
“The minister is a guardian of the mystery of God.”
The minister is a guardian of the mystery of God, not as a gatekeeper but rather as a caution against turning faith into its opposite: certainty.
The second concept is confession. To be a young minister today is exponentially more difficult than it was for ministers of my generation. We were accorded cultural status and privilege in a way not seen today. We did not always use it well, present company not excepted, often becoming chaplains of the status quo.
Churches were growing, not diminishing, in membership and financial resources. The cavernous, sometimes vicious, political and cultural divides of today make preaching far more difficult. One sermon can make us suddenly strangers in the eyes of our people. Churches live with a pervasive anxiety about their survival. Such anxiety can lead a church to make bad decisions.
In such times, we pastoral elders are called to support you and encourage you in all the ways we can.
The third concept is affection. Wendell Berry, in his heralded essay “It All Turns on Affection,” writes that any good work depends on affection. If a minister does not have genuine affection for her or his congregation as they are, the work cannot thrive.
Ministers can come in with a wish dream for the church and withhold affection until they achieve it. Dietrich Bonhoeffer wrote that this wish dream is an idol that is best cast to the ground and shattered. Only then can real ministry flower.
“Love one another with mutual affection,” Paul wrote. Good pastors lead the way.
The fourth concept is leadership. What is true pastoral leadership? The term “servant leadership” has almost become a cliché. It means at least this: The pastor and congregation take turns leading and following.
“If a minister does not have genuine affection for her or his congregation as they are, the work cannot thrive.”
Paul wrote about marriage, “Submit to one another out of reverence for Christ.” It is also true in ministry. This mutual give-and-take, leading and following, embodies reverence for Christ, who is the only head of the church.
Parker Palmer offers profound guidance about leadership in his essay, “Leading from Within.” He first defines a leader as anyone who has an unusual capacity to shed their light or their shadow on another or others. A parent, politician, leader of a business or nonprofit, pastor — most of us have some sphere in which we are a leader. Palmer says, then, it is incumbent upon leaders that they do the inner spiritual work so as to maximize the light they shed and minimize the shadow.
The fifth concept is balance. So let’s talk about the pastor’s week. I have sought to divide the hours of my week into three: First, the preparation of sermons, usually around 15 hours of study and preparation of sermons. Second, pastoral care, usually around 15 hours of pastoral visitation and other forms of pastoral contact — the beautiful old term for this dimension was the “care of souls.” Third, leadership, around 15 hours spent in staff and committee leadership and in the care and nurture of volunteer leadership.
The hours haven’t always worked out just that way, but this was the intent. The pastor is not the CEO, leading from on high. All three dimensions are important. The church is not a corporation but the body of Christ.
The sixth concept is about preaching. The goal is to preach “the whole counsel of God.” The kingdom of God Jesus announced was multi-faceted: justice and joy, compassion, healing and peace.
Today, because of raging injustice in our nation, a minister is tempted to preach justice as the only key on the piano. So are seminaries and denominations. A congregation brings so many diverse needs and hungers to church. A good pastor knows those needs and hungers because he or she knows them.
“Today, because of raging injustice in our nation, a minister is tempted to preach justice as the only key on the piano.”
John Calvin called the Psalms “the anatomy of all parts of the soul.” As biblical preachers, we preach to all parts of the soul of our people.
The prerequisite of biblical preaching is listening. Early in the week, we sit alone with the text or texts for the next Sunday. We sit still so we may hear. We don’t plunge first into the commentaries. Dale Moody used to quip, “The Bible sheds a lot of light on the commentaries!”
Martin Buber gives this seminal advice: “I shall teach you the best way to say Torah. You must cease to be aware of yourselves. You must be nothing but an ear which hears what the universe of the word is constantly saying within you. The moment you start hearing what you yourself are saying, you must stop.”
That is how the minister starts the week.
When I was ordained the year after seminary, the church gave me a Bible I still have on my desk with these words of Scripture inscribed on the first page, from 2 Timothy 4:1-5: “I charge you in the presence of God and of Christ Jesus … : Preach the word, be urgent in season and out of season, convince, rebuke and exhort, be unfailing in patience and teaching … always be steady, endure suffering, do the work of an evangelist, fulfill your ministry.”
Those words describe the breadth, depth and challenge of the pastoral vocation. They have been my guide, however well and badly I have followed.
The last concept is about God and our vocation. The short story writer Andre Dubus tells of an older priest looking over his life. He reflects on the three kinds of young men who go to seminary. The first kind go, he says, as young cadets go into the military, looking to move up in the ranks. The second kind go to manage their neuroses. But the third type go, he says, “to live their life with God.” These, he says, “have a vocation.”
We ministers all have our goodly share of ambition and neuroses. But we will fulfill our ministry if we, most days of the week and in all the tasks of our ministry, seek to live our lives with God.
Stephen Shoemaker most recently served as pastor of Grace Baptist Church in Statesville, N.C. He previously served as pastor of Myers Park Baptist in Charlotte, N.C.; Broadway Baptist in Fort Worth, Texas; and Crescent Hill Baptist in Louisville, Ky.


